COMPARISON OF ENGINEERING PROPOSALS

iii

CONSUL TANT

ASSOCIATED | WCT/DELCAN DAYTON & APLIN TRIFFO
LO KNIGHT MARTIN

Kees ;
Hourly Rates _ 65.00-36.00 175,.00-35. 00 45.00-34.00a/not stated 75.00-40, 60
Estimated fee oa | $65,800 |euns$48, 9002 $50, 570 $57,279 $65,475
Is estimate an upset Y@Seuencuass yes/disclaimlyesassuouess

SCHEDULE -
On time yeS e@arlyueslyes yes yes yes/text no
Times broken down 7 YES esaseeous lyessauascunn [no no no
Realistic . ue .fyes/2 crewse ?-Dec start |?-Dec start ?-Dec start [?-Dec start

SCOPE
Geotechnical OK : Hardyteaeere (Goldersssune Golder cuaeun Hardysesenes Hardysesgeues
Understanding Of projects flexcellentaaa fair/assumes |fair good good
Approval agencies : thorough asad mentioned too late mentioned mentioned
Liaison with City excellentass |good good goad fair
Overdependance on City. NHOssesanowes [possible Possible NOCKCRNEREHA iNCheUN Nee EeeS
Frelim. alt. designs YES ssteeeesslyeseuunanany Yes aueuusuuas [disclaimer yeSauvouuss
Cost comparisons YESstueussaslyesuasenunan yesunaneurss ino YES enuseucen i

fl
Key staff¢ Good sseseees (Qoodwanuanan QOOd baveeuan igoodcacncean gondeasesss
Project staff 900d saeueees [Goodcsssesen weak GOOd sasaununs
Road design ; istrongaccess Strongeseerse [good good
Fump scation design 900d Saecenes lGoodsascaans Good ussscese Flygteaseaca

Flectrical design ? ? - (QoOd sewuxeaus [Shafelikeunn

goods:
good
weak

GENERAL

First discussion with City thoroughesselfair/late fair thoroughsass
Thoroughness of proposal excellentasslgood . typos\fair goo

Extra resources if net... YES @eeneuaas lyesananonuue |?

good
fair
no