- ss5 &ipjRIIhQ ,li; hiil g %II I I R .= K Siih hNP XBF, CORPORATXGN ~%511!1, OF TEE CITX OF PORT COQUXTIAN / ECCNONIC DEVEIDPNENT CCNNITTEE Ai;:EMDA e t I I I I I U I ISI Tuesday„February 2, 19+2 6:00 p.m. (After Planning Committee Neeting) PMCE 4 'NN! N I ~ I I IRR ~ am I I I lml I la hi, „;—;-= Planning Department 6 IggI I,1lhillg I hijijll 1. Mirrctes of the previous meeting. Illi,@ il lhhj ~ gS S'% I 'III I IIjj'ihh @hlhilh l ,'iiii]ll ~ INNN( lji 44miiiwl Wl RR /IR!lhWW "~~'I"- iii& 4'~i',Imlll hi) 2. 1993 Advertising (For Discussion Purposes) 3. Bylaw Correspondence 4. Federation of Canadian Nunicipalities — International Program Plj i i'll(l 6III m II III 1!i Hl kl R II!I &IIFmi I 118111 IINiWwi lhh'Iagl' I ID6 16-1 illlNI 1 I 1 1 IN E NR ' h I I lail I FE8 -p les c — — - —- I: I Ii -— 14 ~ I III Ii % igi 111 le I i di!Im % ~ ... '- 4 I i!i s m I' I lj III 1 II i s'4 I~ ' - ~;I eall el ~ ~ I ' I 11 tom ~ ' I I 'Pt!1 4111 I DI I 8 IR i I i«i M I's !+if Illa li I il 14 'lima ~ 4! IN 'I 4 4 s I lm I I S 411 I( I :8'[lR' :Il ll 'ji kl " ~gglg II "I IIIII II I IRRRHHIHLg',", ~l ~ L» ~THE 8 .|j, — ~ ~444EI+ INII~RRINEIe = PIIIRRIII ORPORATION OF THE CITY QF PORT COCjIXXLAN ECONONIC DEVELOPMENT CONN~TH regular meeting of the Economic Development Committee was held in the Planning Departuent on: Tuesday, February 2, 1993 at 6400 p.m. A %II/IEI )Ill 111 In attendance were: il I Councillor N. Gordon, Chairman Councillor N. Wright, Co-Chairman Carlos Felip, Di.rector of Community Planning CONFIRMATION OF NINUTE54 Recommended: That the ninutes 'f the meeting of the Economic Development Committee held on Tuesday, Januarv 5, 1993 be taken as read and adopted. jllil RQI III Ill II jul »»» ~ I.SI ~ I'ijl'iil l. SlWIIIg 1993 Advertising (For Discussion Only) 4'lfm!II budget After some discussion, it was proposed that a limited advertising national in a advertise to used for Econcmic Development for this year be in local magazines, magazine, such as the Trade and Commerce. Advertising this year. implemented not be will Trade, and Board Vancouver like the )Riti~yj for That the Bylaw Department be advised that any application as a treated be residence "Contractors'icences" to be operated from a home-based business. I..'LI II I IIII f i Illllllj jl Ir» I... ~m \ IMI4 »1 3. Federation of Canadian Municipalities — International Program 4 SS ~ 1.11 im »I »»»1m At 6:30 p.m. I" Sl ~ III the meeting adjourned. I I Counci j.lo+Nl Gordon Chairman '» 1 Ml IIi, ii ( f I'1III"»I II I S =- . 1 I 1ml ~SS m»r. (g'» i. Is» ls I ~ .~ »... '1 4 4 II » I II SSS I '1 1 I»»»» DSI'IPI,IIms I ml ~ Il»IS» » II 'I ': I u» I 'I ''— I il'I I I 'IILI . — I'»4 ,; Ill ill I.I ~ »I . 1»elgl lmlh~cwllt' ~ I I I ~ ~ » la t:: ~S4 IS Ms: %le% Smm»l 4 I~ I ass siss»m: Ilims ~ I II 'IIII',ll I I . 2 1993 FEB ID616-2 ""'.; — ' lIlIIIIIH I I ' I» NIL'I Ilg I@I! III 1 I I Il II4II Qlrr~1 I I IM »» Federation That the document "Together We Can Change Our World" from the b, received. — Program international of Canadian Nunicipalities „,.IS „., a IISI/$ I'l'hfhl h ~ »» II IIII,IIjlHI 44 I S;;'~ ill Recolmen~: I IIN III I'I I II II I%II I I J&h%ii Carried RLIN& III msmsI 'll Sl I!%II l'jill/ RecommendndI g( ((] f f/I Ill!Ng/ Bylaw Correspondencc 2. 11 I Pl 1» i Rl 1 )g/, ~ zgsJmm,, E ~ 8I II I / SamlsJ/ tg RNJ 'l g Iffy Iss, IE I)! IIIII I IE III+ I J, IIII IRS!! ILI 8 I gI It Ig!!Q!$ I8I 8' 8 ~ lil~!FIICK THE CORPORATION OF THE CI1Y OF PORT COQUITLAM III13I'II ~1I )IS lysis's ~ I I illll) N faire sm,'ia"Ril !'jill'EMORANDUM Mls&I 1.81$ TO: !gg FROMII !ill!I IPJ RE: Economic Development Committee DATE: ih IS) Ilail January 1S, 1993 I I!I I S!f I Iggll lw!HEN !M I I m 8I 88 1 ~yii'8 Idyll I I gf Ill II C. Felip ~ 1993 Advertising : .Illl I/I, I I Ili IIRISN i'4', 1IR Ig III'OR j iiiisll DISCUSSION PURPOSES: In 1992 the Economic Development Committee made the decision to advertise ,iiN!II tt8~ in the following publications: 1. 2. IIII!!Jij!J!!I! l88l8tlls llggs ~ ~ ! I I !IE!III, ~ II I I II li,l tÃI1 :I I 8 gai Islll ~ 8,lt8t ~ 8l ~ le Response: ~ 18 ~I ~l~ 8 I R I!E Ill I I Trade & Commerce Magazine Vancouver Board of Trade Sounding Board Publication + ~ I ~ IIRRIPIUIB I 1. 2. IIIKI Trade and Commerce Magazine — 6 Vancouver Board of Trade — 0 NKjg liiiiill I Ii IIEII I R! /i! aJI iitII g ~~ teJpe8, For 1993 the Economic Development Committee has a reduced budget of for advertising. The Committee should discuss advertising strategy for 1993. I Om )'! 8 iiha ' I 8 8 msl !I] !!', I@II)!, IIlklt 'E Ital R g I II IE '= '! II fl III 'I I !II' Carlos Regist I I II 8 il /[li",I I A.C.I.P. rector of Planning 15 ll ~ I II' DV Ima 'i ll I I gl l II I'ilt,j l!~', IIIS Ias s IsI II6IWH IIII I F II A J I %!5IPg I I!elI1! )lii!!& I ''''RN tl I 'I 11 lmt Jl tl Zll I'I : ' I I TD616/3 I It II FEB I8 — '1993 /. ''.5 'I U 8!I 8 IJRII IIIH8f I 'I'I I l — .=i»»~i gylsnszsm)'IINIEINIINNg ,„,I JI'J Ill IIml I gjI= 1~= — — -*-«1 ~ HRVI~" "'-:, g~(jl)mllhll N .:-: — — I ~ I-6'-. e Ia III@=1;,;;gll,jlINF 'jlj/ 4gN I — '',-" I =...", B+&~N I!ISlmjli~~iiImjmjjmg~ — - — ~4ISRIIl%1mjmmI %5 l I Ng Ngha - Il IIII al4 O'lzj ljm dl II IMIII I II Im EI 4 ""ll -i $1 f I5II8 8 I I I sLI I I I I I I RLI IS M)l WS IS I 14 gi'irl F Rmmj111 S gy h 448 III ggs I Sl Ii I'I I ILIEI la«1 ilailE hhl E» —:— hl ~ le '4 1 I I I I I' llr I II h ~ ~ II XIII I l j.l I 11I I lljIjlji /IIIIJIII.I j I I I ilI 1411 I lji 4' «1. 'I ~ i January 14, 1993 Carlos Felip JAM DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE 2580 Shaucrhnessy Street Port Cocuatlam, B.C. II I ' I « 1111 ""O'I .hIT8 V3C 2A8 ml ~ '.hh I Dear Carlos Enclosed please find details on our readership and advert'. g for the SOUNDING BOARD: the official Journal of The Vancouver Boards of Qiiiil I i The SOUNDING BOARD reaches the absolute core of the Vancouver business community...the CEO's, decision-makers and other leaders of business. Our next issue has something that, should be of particular interest to you. Zn the February issue of the SOUNDING we look at attracting business to the cities and towns BOARD, of British Columbia. We shall explore those areas that can offer companies, that wish to branch out from the Lower Mainland, extraordinary opportunities in those cities. our editor points out..."There are many advantages: Lane costs are often lower. Access is often more convenient. Commuting time for and your employees can often be reduced. And if you'e shipning oryou receiving hard goods, a location near the airport, docks, rail lines or truck routes can be a time and money saver as well, In addition, many mid-career people who have dreamhed of "somedav" moving to a small community, where the pace is slower, are finding that "someday" is now. SOUNDING BOARD looks at some of the lifestyle and economic factors behind this trend to smaller communities, Here is an opportunity to reach the people that. make the decisions that could benefit. your community. Our rates are well below the glossy magazines and we give you a high calibre, well targetted readership. Thank you for considering the SOUNDING BOARD. I shall call you shortly to discuss further . ]lI'll fll'IIIIIIIJ I11%1m8 I I 1lg hh I I II ~ ~ s I '",;;. Illi; I jIOIX. " ' I miR',i&i8j As «0 « IE I fslEIIi PORT COQUITLAM ECONOMIC 'ljl!Ill I I I %Isa ilSII]) 18 Igg Yours truly I Hj'III I Trade. Ol I jlLlt h EPL s I I lliai IHI'ljll,lj Ian Andkew Jamieson I SOUNDING BOARD 203 — 970 Homer Street Vancouver, B.C. V6B 2W7 (604) 681-1811 Telephone (604) 681-0486 Fax 4 'I I h FEB 'I IW ~ 44s e l I I 84s ~ II 114 2 1993 ~ 1 I —,;l5':::=:="mgm /gl!i ~ ""% ~ aeslllPIIIIIIIN PI1as~~mlllgg N '%III mIII,I m 'l Jf)Hiiil FI I I ill@ IIIII il I I I»'~~'eall, I SOUM3ENG BOrfRDreaches VancouvcFs best business readership. Thc Vancoura'oard of Trade am . III SR VBNCOUVFN count amongst its members thc top Bxms iu ell indusuy sectors. The Vancouver Board oETxadc is thc city's chsniber of commerce. Since 1887 The Board hsc been tbe voice oE business in Vancouver, working in the iritezcst ofits xuembcrs to promote, IPIISIIIIil B enhance snd fsciTitate the devxdopmen t of the region as a Pscigc centre for txsde, commcrce and uavcL Board of Trade members are active. Tllcll'exuapsrc ill comnrittees and task forces snd attend the Bexiuent luncheons, seminars snd zcccptions otfered by The Board. They know the value of nenvoriung, of pardcip*ring in the'u cotmuunity snd of staying hzfo trued. nlsil)'oatd Filtll HOW SUSINSSS I,BlUm SIAF I('lliiii' rar IW 8 I%I ~w 5 5 lg ) )III IIILH1 II IP 'e el I I I I I I SOUNDING BOARD 51 &)Ill'5 iii,wilt brings you more frequency, more circulation and a fresh neTo look hFOB NEO Thmugh SOfBVDIVG BQrfRD nxcmbers keep in touch with Board of Trade news and acrivities. They hear about poHc& developinents, inirdisrives snd u ends in borh the public and the private sectoa. They leam oEthe key points of The Board's Frequent prexenzsrions by noteworthy international spcalms and read shout opportuniries to get involved in upcoming sctivitics of speriBc inter at to than. SOVIVDINC BOrfBLYs n.vrs stoxics, cdiroxisls, fesnacs snd Focus sccrion pmvide timely covasge of iimes that have a bauing on doing business ia Vencouva; SOV1VDBVG BOrfBD brings yoin + News an Boad activities and analysis, and commentary aud e An expended Small Business News secrion that deah with topics snd issum ofsperigc mterest to compsnieswith fewer than 10 employees "How to" sad analyris xrridcs, taking sdvsntsgc of the professiorul expertise of our members Progles of the diverse and hxtezearing business people in Vancouver's business conunurdty... aad sorus exemplar f uue innovsrion in IIM'IImeeL SNPII burixtess ~agm a DetaHs oa oew benc6ts aad ineenuves available to you as merob ere of The Vancouver Board of Trade $0111VDING BQr1RDis iced by leading bminas execurives, btrdudhxg sl! members of The Vancouver Board oFTrsde snd tbe Worid Trxdc Centre Vancouver. SOUfVDZVC BOrr~ has 13,000 prunsry subscnbexs snd a comexvarively esrirnsted total readership of 30,000. SOEBVDBVGBOr1RDis distributed via addressed mail to all manbers of Thc Vsacouver Board of Trxde. 1t is aho sent to fed srxl, provincial snd civic elected repr. seatstive, inguenriai business derision-mskcrs, selected boards of asde snd chambers of conunerce saoss Canada snd Bziush Columbia ntedia representixivcs. Copies are made available to attendees ct Board functions, inriuding snd the Business After Business minI-bade shows. Additional copies ae disuibuted to buretcsses in the mein commerce districts of Vancouver. III IIII'P IJIVVI 5 I SINII N Fi gl Nil Fg 1 II g SSH Iif gi amg i II 5R)I II .ll1lPI ) IIIIIIPP Il iriii ii ia I iiiil,'ll I I I,R Ill 'IIli II I I ll,gl III I Nlllii) IIIII'I statements on Board posirions on pofic and topical issues e Hard urionnation (names, addresses, Iisrings) tbst hss a dicca inQuencc on business opp oftum ucs i I ua Is i i xi i ,m re e IR FEB "2 1B93 e ~ [II'lllll f Members'eceptions IIPiiii SOUiidBlgg08fd IHE VOICE OF SUSINSSS IN miiiI'I I IIISI i ~ ima iiiii 4 II I Fl L ggg z IML g ' B Ill ~P~ E1n is+ill[ QI !!!A!ItIlllj&IIIIIRL!!L iiil lllti EE jgj/ I 'IS II 1 Ill Ill II ~ ~@II ~ ~RW ESaa!a! mm IIIifILIIRIIII '!'III I%III( I I Ilail 1~m)) 'iIE I I liljlliW!II NSPUI(Y AQVERTlSING RAg Rn gs IIIII II%~ ~ V! I fftuREER I )x INCERRGNS 1495 1340 1037 1/6 Page ...,................„. BI% Ilt!ELIII '"'~ Il"t Bi 3 I I i I I SITE ~ ' $ '1 ' I I ! '' Iwlt Eml ew'' I!.Sme Im I f I II II Slf ~ e I 14 ~ II I 1166 1045 810 678 540 465 384 307 599 1421 1241 1112 1645 1267 1437 1108 1350 1457 1343 1079 905 789 713 625 537 852 1369 1263 1014 350 742 'I027 1667 153? 1235 1035 903 316 715 847 975 1990 1597 1890 1517 1652 1325 1731'335 Full Page,..................,... 1755 161 8 1300 1089 .951 Three Columns .............. Magazine Page .............. 1/2 Page .....,.................. I/3 Page ......................,. 1 m Page 1 Column....................... I/6 Page ....,.................. Basebar ...............,........ ,859 .753 .696 861 722 575 495 409 328 637 1041 Copy content and design: All advert!sing content and design must be acceptable to The Vancouver Board of Tmde, which reserves the right to postpone or refuse, without penalty, Magazine Page „..„...,.... Fossmmua Fug Page,...,....,....„„,.... Three Coiumns ...........,.. 2011 1911 1799 1893 c) d) ISSGES AND ( LGSING f)ATTS Re-dere receive BOUNDIAIG BOARD approximately the first of each month except July. Deadlines for advertising space ordure and editorial copy,!re generally the end of the tlrst week of the month prior (please see next page for exact dates). Please direct ag editorial inquiries to the editor and ag adverllelng Inquiries to Advenlslng In Print. Shuns " Buaer " Bars Fug-Page ..................,......,......,.10-1/4 Three Columns.„.......,.....,......,. 6-1/l6 Magazine page,...,.....,....,........, 8-3/16 1/2 Pago..............„.......,....,...... 10-1/4 1/3 Page: 801 Magazine Page .............. 1561 1/2 Page .....................,.. I/3 Page ......,................. I/4 Page ......................... 'l309 1206 ......,....,......,, 1013 . 900 1283 1484 1243 1145 'l066 962 855 1219 'I121 1552 1245 1569 1476 1218 1001 940 875 790 702 930 841 747 1065 dial'I Ae 587 504 1670 1570 1296 1086 publkatlon of any advertlsement, Production charges: A surcharge wiE be levircd lf work ls not camera-ready. Production costs will be provided upon request. Cancsllatlons and liability for error. Maxln!um uablllty for error is restricted to the space rate for the advertisement. Advertising Agency Commission: Accredited advertising agencies please nota that rates are commissionablo for payment within 30 days of publication. b) '70 -square.................,................ 6.1/!6 —vertical ........,............................ 4 — horizontal ..„......................,.. I 0-'I/4 I Column ................................. 1-7/8 I/4 Page.......,......,...,.....,.....,..... 5-'I/3 15 15 10 ill)IIII 7-1/2 8-3/16 12-1/2 5 15 7-1/2 Pfllll 1/8 Page: 1021 -vertical ...,.......,....,................. — horizontal .............,.............„ Bass bar ......................,............. Business Cards,.........„......,....... ,III, NI IIIII, IA 1001 9 lg RII' Full Page „,............,---- ......... 2248 iii Magazlne Page ............... ......... 1 860 1868 2136 1766 1M4 " "- 192 I 11 1 I I I I II 1754 'l450 1195 Random position through out paper, One mvoice for 11X. ..... Prices upon request Irnears 7 percent GST appgcable. ---- -""- NEO!AN!OS SFMIRCETIONS SOUNDING BOARD Is printed an SB-52 fgsm Electrabrite stock. I'Aodmum line screen ls 85 to 100 Ines per Inch. Text size is 10/ 11 point. Tabloid Image size is 10-1/4'ide X 15'n height. The hrblcid format ls five columns of 11-1/2 pleas, 6 point per column (1-7/8'). IIIIl I'I II I I I I I Nz i ll! i aIl,' I f1 I I I ei! i11 1 'll $ 1 il I! ' 203-970 Homer Stre t Vancouver, B,C. V68 2W7 Telephone: (604) 681-1811 Faro (604) 681 -0456 8140 per heading per year for Vance wer Board of Trade members only; 31 80 per heading per year for non-members (rates effective I May t, 1991). IB II IL Ihll'ii I il SFIIAE anaaaNTEED )40SIOGN I ~ I I ei! 20 psr cent over space rate ir'il FEB '!e E(1 II za II I'1 "I I ',I IU I iii 1111 lII II II! ADVERTISING IN PRINT EJASSIRED BIITERS'0IDE I II JJ I 11 e I ADVERTISING REPRESENTATIVES 1 ll IIl) I a z )611 '! 68IERAL REGGULoous Ovrsne Bees Coven 1/6 Page ......................,.. Sassier . ......,................ a t)jx Twc-Caress 1 Column z 4 Bassbar,...................,... Ouunm Sax Cows Full Page ....................... Magazine. Page .............. Full Page ....................... /SI Llillll I bx 1274 986 826 657 567 467 375 729 .869 .692 .596 .492 ,394 ,767 I Column...,...........,..., IIil IIII' I / 3x a) Brats zae Wsos Full Page ...............,..„., Three Columns ............. Magazine Page ............. 1/2 Pago,...................... 1/3 Page.......,.....,......... I/4 Pape ........., ............. 1 ne I -2 1993 c: =::1!e1 Q j» ' kh I SI 114 tf 1 gm~ III II I I II L I I 1 2 II I'8! II 1m I IIII' II I II fIII III IIllll as I .'='", — '!'"=": m am,aas I lg I-'l JI 4'I tu 8 =-:"- 'Il''"„". 'I 4 llililltlmgiiIII'n&" l glgl-l"--': -"'"-: 1 'g sltlllul. I 1 ll-ll ~ IIIIltamt Iasass Il „III',"-." lgg lt .,... a II1gml, I I I-:tl l l II I I II ~ su::: 8w 0 gg I ~ 1 881 1811 . ur-l I ll I I I 1 I I I II'lJlllll g 51!iII [,II ismIIiI' fg lmm il jl IN1 ur'e I w aa I It~i I I cl'Ie cl'I ~ lgglI/lit il Imlllll l~ tg Pi Iaulr Copy of 1992 ad IIIJII'::; ei P ort Ilmli) 0 m I cn Ie u mar! 1m 'I I 4 I tg i IM 11 I I Ill%i i ra ill I g IIII.l.'tlg ml 1 IC loquitlarrt III Im II,' 11 i)( berated approximately 30 minutes from downtown Vancouver, easy access to the UBA and the Trans Canada Highway, Bordered by the Coquitlam and Pitt Rivers and backed by majestic mountains to Ihe north, the City offers a mixture offend uses residential, industrial, commercial and illlltIII recreation are!ss. Our new Indseqrial and commercial areas offer great opponunities for new i 'development and business serving B.C. and the Pacit'ic Rim markets. Zlra Dominion T issngle provides an opportunity for mixed developrnentl industrial, highway commercial, and business park. South of the Lougheed Highway are the CP Rail Yards and the ssdnry Eii ll Industrial IIifill, m al I lglSI II u 8 gg I I III IIIIIII'h l I ,J gstnrs which has a mixture oE heavy and general mdustnal uses. Erysrfdfsn industn'al Park Phase l is located along the Pitt River and provides home for Old Dutch Foods, Yamaha Motor Canada. Trace Canada Clearings and I1HI more. Phase U will be starring soon. FOR FURTMSR CNFORCsCATION CONTACT: City ol Fon Coqult ram, Sronornlc Development Ollice, Shaushnessy Street, pars Coquiuam, S.C. V3C ~o TEL f404) 944.5442 FAX (404) 944d404. II]Il , os e Il ttt% +10 I . II I lIs I 4 14'I ggliil I 1 kl IIIII «ii 'I ~ i I "ILI Ill II I f II" I'l' 1 'I ' III'III IIII ll II II~bllII II Iul s II ~~ I s 'l ~ iiii ll o FEB -2 1gg3 :nell ''I al S 'f14 ~ I I I I I al I IS I II ~ I l I t,l I II I sl l (fg 1 I I I' I I I Nilii IL ' I I ltll s I I ~ II a" 1 ill id'~I'lI I el I; c II ' 'sl s I IIIII 'I s sl sos -ml I I II I 'ml I uo s sm —— ss II ll g Irmilr~ sl llamIE a fl'Imi THE CORPORATION QF THE Ihm SHW I IIII& I CITY OF PORT COQI."ITLAN 1I WII iN! lJ! Iaaf M III Sl E Pili Sll a Nl!'l I )Pi i DATE: l! ii'Pl iii'ili)l FRON: Carlos Felip Director of COmmunity Planning 5 llml JRI Ilmi Ron Criggie llrm IIJ Chief Licence Inspector a Bylaw Enforcement Officer II IIII ,/ji IPii SUBJECT: 1 )) e considered III %f ~Sari Accessory Home Business Licence Applications versus Contractor Applications with Residential Addresses nl i »~a/i i O'IN SS Home Based Businesses? I i EXANPLE I 111IH]kl II Qllll please confirm to this department by way of memo under what conditions an applicant for a Business Licence as a Contractor with a residential address in port Coqutilam would be required to apply under the definition of an Accessory Home Business Use (Section 512, Bylaw 2240). As contractors do use their homes for office purposes and do bring home work vehicles from their tradei are they II„LIIPI/ Ilk 'III I»afnafl January 21. 1993 II PPIPI Ill j',Wrl! Ken's Clean Concept Carpet Care was located as a Contractor on June Crescent in port Coqutilam but has since moved to a multi family dwelling unit on Fortress Diive. This business does carpet cleaning and I am sure that a truck is used in that bu iness. Would they be permitted to do this? Should the Business Licence be approved? I! PNllllI IIIBk I''ll =!!'p'ri I ISS I I I I EEEa k,I i~~ ig n " Ii lisas ri i, s r II Rl( Pl 888 I rlilll I' i Il ill I R5 I% IIr I'I . I II I " i IR . I I I I ~ Iiiih P i' I alii i'wii! 0 Iil. Pl I PS '. I i ~ I I iriP til RGB~ I 'iit'II FEH-2 893 i I II I a -':-fa ll»1 I la II aa 1 I'» I flliiRI $ i i 1i l 'r'IA I R.G. Criggae Chief Licence Inspector S Bylaw Enforcement Officer PIIEPPLI i Ili5 Ii I pg lp [ Iii ii I e c: I PII I'I, IPP'll ia .Ii il PII'If f PP %I ~ I .Pl ljil ii IPII al Il 1~~~ „ ~ ~5gl15 I gi 5~II)SSSS Ng —— ': "'MI~ si~itl ERI&m4 opa sm as Nll il g Sl mii iIR 1411'l I'l SSSISSI„ I)/ I ~ IPP I IR I@ 44444lmp!SP4% ~~~g mRIIIIIN5~i& I swill SM (g ~~WIII Iee~ Epmlm 5 !ssqi I !-- 'I'~1+!P55gm gll~m -'~p!iSIIIBMR eepee ' 41psslpsssslee I .—'P i]]llj Iipl@iolig ~ pppl4+ — IIIIIN ml ~ IMI IISI I ips 1II Federation of Canadian Munieipahties International Program ,IJ'lk) loftier I ll''a&ag !ill 3IPIIN we eipr! ehapp(e oppr worl!I IIILJ 1% Nil l I'll'I IIP g;= =S!II h el I! lgl~a P 'g!ei Ill mP!1!Pe ' h) !pl Pl lie IIII I P IPPIi III Ih Hl. 4 ' Is l le elle e e j lg jJ P!e!!!IIII IpIISI' ~IS@!~ I l O'Pl a si I ~ ~ ~ I I I %PI le I 11 ~ 4 Ig,y I let; —.:" ilk)l Illll = I Il!I I' I P II Sl 41» ee I 1 gJII !11 ITI I I N el ~ ~... I I ! P kl I I!4 1 I L I III e I 'fill;.''' - I I I I ! I ~ I II I P!! II!! IPI N I f ip - III .!4 4S.—. - &&!xl I WISSSS!P I I I I SR -.": '-:III 555 m '8 IP ~ -se Ip=" '.';" % I ~ 4 i ~ 'ppe I I '!I! I! p !!! p! I I ~ FEB I I 14 I IS ~ IS ~ -2 lgg3 -;4 - sii ~ 4 Sill lip ... IIII 'I gill I Table of Contents Introduction Wa 411 slsel lie ~ III it II $ 111tl i ij Letter fmm Monique Landry, Minister for External Relations and International . Development .........., „............,....,......... ll!S Sil Ai Letter from Alan Tonks, President of Task Force on International Programs Together we can change our world Municipal cooperation Decentralized cooperation: Experience with International Municipal Assistance Program tiles N il?AI gllllfll I'III 4 '11141 W$ II I I le f1 l I ~ 'I I iii ritj ii I I I I 11 I I S! I! ii. II /ill I ie1 144 4 I'It 11 I ~ Ii =. -S = '::l,ii I 17 SASKATOON-GRENADA Canadian Water Meters in the Antilles 21 MZUZU-COB OURG Bridges to Progress 25 ALMA-BOGANDE Helping Hands Between Lac St-tean and GnaGna . 29 A New Focus From North to South 33 i[gj 4 I 4 I I lell i International development week 41 4 I e Why Participate in International Development Week? I I ' ~ I 4 l I I I FCM International l Ss III l i s II'i.. I' 1i Week............... 39 Program........................... 41 1..'ll 41 II Il.t Sit i li II Proclamation of International Development tit IA I 4 41 L'll III What can your municipality do for International Development Week? I ~ ls! s al Resources and useful contacts 4 'l. IFEB ~ II el I: I s s 2 1993 I 'l I CALGARY Activities in China - an update I!1 g '( ter II g'iii= 1 4 2 II II, Jlljjm Il Jtedsnation of Canadian MnniofFalitios 455 (!Ill salg/ llgi gl Jif 'tt ssa tna '8',AN'iveries ~i I fr g enj $ This document has been prepared by the 'JIII NIIIIt( Iltil/ I I\i Ir II I I ~ I jLIIFjj ' J jill'5 Fedeprttion of'nnadiutn Jtfnnicitafitias International Office with the collaboration of its members and the financial support of the Ptsblic Petsrfcipaiion Program (PPP-CIDA). lk III jjj IIIIIII I ~!!Nj.-"":~l IIIII'» jIIj 1llkl I Il'"ll'III I!4t, .I III Ijjjj Also collaborated to the production of this document: 'I 1 till Pll I ll' PATRICIA McCARNEY Center for Urban and Community Studies, University of Toronto ' "Ijjl ini il I Article: Decentra1iized cooperation - Experience with International Municipal Assistance Programmes I illj',3 181 I j IK I ~ III I Q I i Ia ig I IIIII RGIA I''.'. III »a ~ ~ O'Il )I fl I'l I I 'j te i [sat Is il l s I t j Cooperative d'experts-eon setto Page layout and folio ving articles: SASKATOON-GRENADA, Canadian Water Meters in the Antilles; MZUZU-COBOURG, Bridges to Progress; ALMA-BOGANDE, Helping Hands Between Lac St-Jean and GnaGna; A New Focus From North to South; and section on International Development Week a a R. I I 'I Is its Printed by: RUNGE PRESS LTD ': sj I 14 OTTAWA& JANUARY 1993 I le :isa gl Nso' IL ils4IN il i il LS I IIR= '--'. 44m4n I4iNssi ~ ~ ~ INiIII nlliil44 -- - -"."=:'N » N iisiN elise ~ is a ~ I l I ICE 44illl g'l I 141IIIIP ilim m i« J ', Ill @ ~ I I i i , mm iN i II I SSiS' ~ Ss s s : 144S 1 I . ~ I ~ N ~ —',', ss rl I I 4 1 sti' I i 14, hfinister /or External Rehtions and International Development IIII III Rl m444 ~ 8 11 ll Ill e ;,"=:~ '=(libel( III g I I To all members of the Federation of Canadian Municipalities II1I I h :PA s44nI I li - 'Rllfli I IIII ni li I ll44 Iig Preparations are now under way for International Development Week 1993, and I would like to invite members of the Federation of Canadian Municipalities to participate in it. As Minister for External Relations and International Development, and simply as a Canadian, I attach great importance to this nation-wide effort to raise awareness of development issues. Because International Development Week creates a feeling of shared global community, it is in my view, one of the best means of preparing Canada for the next millennium. /) 8illll IIIIEI (1Llei I Silk 44+44~ ~ Nl 'g ANNNs i ~ ~ 44LII -- -=;a lllll l ii4) '" %II! I'I l.I,III I I,'-,- IIII', =,.'-ji I'Jl iiit 4 S Development Week, which is being ~ 1 to 7, 1993 will focus on the need for partnership among Canadians and with held February in 4Ni' II iiiii i I '-"'. I TOG~ II Il I il l '::IIll,",I , g To those of you who are already committed partners, I ask that you do as you have done in the past and help encourage Canadians to participate in International Development Week and its awareness activities. ill ii lrii has been chosen calls on Canadians to workpeople the developing countries. The slogan that together because We Can Ch ange Our World. Through your activities, you can play a leading role in your community. Your contritution last year showed how effective you can be in this area. I would like to thank you again for your valuable participation in International Development Week 1992 and for the time and energy you, and our other partners, devoted to making it a real success. i 4 I."'=" III us 11 li I ~ Ul We are counting on you. TOGETHER we ~tl ~ . f can do more and we can do better. YOURS SINCERELY, N MONIQUE LANDRY I IN I iu"' $ '' ''' FEB-2 $93 " "R I I I ~ ~ NNS 4'g I 4I' IL Itnlll Rl I/g - -. Lia sis Saaii LIIIR '"S IIIllnl~4s~ s~~- g//g 11 ilk IIIIjiiIINIia ' 'is .M 41 1 NmNnl [yQ ($ i I I I I PS ','eu II II',, )gtni =.:..':.i 'IliiLIIHll I i s .» IaraRIIII N L gl g$ RNI itll II nlll illlIIEe I 'I nn RI I% 'll IS 4 4il IIII II II I I I I ~ I I I Eefesntion og Canadian Mnnicipalities j,lllli II Iifl ii)'II,IIIII IIIII'llllll Iaaf II llll 4 II Il li il Iimil I Il 11 ~ I &W III I In I I 1 ~ I a i'l 'II i I I'T 3 III lli 1 , I IIR BI. I I III iii 1i IL I IM I 'I I Ii I i4 M II I ' jj11 8'&L, IPI ll j'fk lj1 II Illa 4ii'= lihll e illI 1Iki I I II et I nial i IIIII'lemm JLIII)I i IIIIII 44411 )i ~ ~ III '' Imli mnlilll le . ! g u !5IIP 55 III,"1! f lil II 1 g &" ll~a&! 555 5L 5i',I 5XWRA all II III I r lRs',I II Federation of Canadian Municipalities Fdderation canadienne des municipalites jll,51$ I!-":::"!I[llimll, Dear FCM members, liii iiii l Hag ggI igi piiii &5ti''il Ill'5515 I I u 5,ill( I!llr II'M ' I i(5jl lllll Illilil .I I Ial R = -. Rltglil I IguRlii I ,a salsal llfl Ii isisl L I III II I la ! i%I 5itI -''-'sr I I I illhl! Rl II nl ill lg I I'l I s I Ililif, ill gt IIIIII ! I II III ' ii saitli I II%I Ill II . I Yours sincerely, llm III '' I 15iiiiiil5'-'-'"''t IS I'I I I ji ia t Su nm I ~ saa util I II I%I III I 1I i FCM is proud to participate in International Development Week 1993. Local leaders must see their challenges in a global context. With this in mind, it should be clear that efforts must continue to support Canada's contribution to improving the quality of life around the world. 5 I Iml I express our deep appreciation to the Canadian International Development Agency for its support. The work of our International Office and our Members is enhanced by CIDA's confidence and encouragement. '41lllll I I .. 'Ilearsm siii rnl tM Yet we are aware that local government is a prime force in Canada's development. We understand, therefore, tha, we can give support to local governments in developiiag countries. Our efforts in strengthening local goveriiment at home and abroad is good for Canada and the world. Ijll!ll ,1, II II55 t 'lIlllf 5555 International Development Week provides an opportunity for you to express hope in making Canada and the world a better place to live in. Municipal governments in Canada confront difficult political and financial realities. We must strengthen our position among governmental structures in Canada. We must challenge the heavy burden of the recession and its effects on loca! government finances. e Chairman Alan Tonks Chair Task Force on International Programs II ,'lijl I ggglllRI FEB -2 5093 II IIIII S I I'i gg II(Qlg 'I( 8I IIJIL=-='-~tni~~;;—.——: :-:-"" ~ ~IIIM9 ~NI io gii198gg/$ 51NIRIIH I, gg@~ ~( ~~&+ ~igi~lli I g~~ Ili ~~ "=,'- ~mmillais- -=~ag@UI gjmle I%II! ISa 9jgi~g li[SI 4Q$ pgjjjggg~ ".",-~In'uiiiiissa9g IL" I ~a~sRu~]~-:e-- — -@f~l~l jp IWIII III I] fg ms w' ~ N~ms mll IQ Q Q;I g gg jm HS Together we eon change onr worM ' IaI I I I ".:9) gg! I l51 III To liaiiai eitl 4!4 9 9511~ 9$BRSI Issi g KSI 4!F4 Hllll scull / I ilN1954 9j !jill jl 11 1! ias jm jjaeas assay 9 I Ill RW g M 1 R I n lg gl L 'd j I 84lil 'lllht 'ssu'1l r'I I i I mn I I i,""I'. . I Ii IL'. ==:"; partnerships common through " market "" ': '.: ' .. '..." 1-.. 91 iiiimi l. I'4! ai~i)i Ilj9lgj I)RI 4 Iarg ildii i i" is 9 9 .,:.'.:'4i r. ill llk ill I , jl!I li. illl —" " Iee— I! I II IPlc'- .;; sill !i 'll ' realities experienced elsewhere, in other economies and in other cultures, International ~epelopnsent even states: Recit .gtVeS .uS tlge'pportttnittt,to:,'enelv our, interest government, as in the and sh are. Our ConVECtton former Soviet Uruon, structures and where national they are affirming at the same time their desire to be art of a s upra- national economy. . commitments are that, the 9Vorid AaS,: Changedr 'eneficial in many ' and that Our muniCP4al:inSt4- ways. In addition to ~~o lsaVe tO hare th benefits generated by . II I'I I!$ , . ':experienc and their:.. 'kno9'vledge with'heir coun.terparts'i.n'ther regions of countries cities of but also all sizes. Everywhere we find new immigrants. Small and ~ge businesses have international ramifications, and are linked with the rest of the world by the new communications technology. In addition, people are travelling more, either for business or for pleasure, and are increasingly exposed to the reality of other countries. The world has changed. In this context, it is in Canada's activities, municipal elected u $1 I at! 'I II II II program officials and professionals can see our own living and working conditions in a broader perspective. They can also better appreciate our own capabilities and freedoms, and realize how important it is to pursue our cooperation efforts at the local level with a view io sharing our basic values and our management methods. Canada, local authorities have developed expertise in many fields such as urban planning, democrafic participation, FEB-2 lgS3 I E 1'', III ;',-'nternational lllij'liiii II interest to encourage municipalities wisldng to be involved in international activities. This kind of experience helps municipal authorities and the local community become more aware of the communication has eliminated distances. Nations are engaging in (4 IPIM II ll 8Rillli The worldwide movement of goods andpeopleisincreasingataveryrapid rate. The emergence of new means of I I IJ III III!I 'i'l IUI Ii I'Ir» III I I I Ill 1 !94 I ~ I I 4,I! sui,j RI.I il I 5 I ~ 9'I I I 111 I Isi 'ill I I R- T ~j SI I Kin «I S::-=' --=:-'"'" "hill milo a I la a" Ia hnII I n! ~ I! !NUgg,g~,"!g;~,,=..-,SS a ,— =IIIN I — 'Q(g/g j gllll ljhllgi m)la!gU& Il! L=~~sSNlg~al~iiS~I I! ~~ = ~~!alai 'll I'll!g/3 relationships between elected officials and the private secator, and environmental protection, to name only a few. It is important to share this knowledge with local authorities throughout the world, and especially with those who express the desire to do so. While contributing to the promotion aaa IIII ~ IS II II «jj 'll I Federation of Canadian ijfunieipalines ()LI lash»I i I I jieiil iai Iil Ill» I') jl) obvious economic benefits and further our International human and social values. the Week us opportunity Development gives and share our to renew our interest conviction that the world has changed, and that our municipal institutions have to share their experience and their knowledge with their counterparts in other regions of the world. III sll'Skll I I g 55 II I SI I of local government, we can achieve ' )Ill I!5I Jgj I III ala Ial! .Iljj'Ul lFij. IIIIIII 'SI Ii ! 1 sa ~ S~ ~ ijl lII IIIS jp.aiiali III ::: -'-'.:":! I! . i I! It! @I jllfi7iii I IIS I I jgjlilll 5/ lj,))NI [gKIIS! ! 115ISISI S S alll III jaa[IIIII a's Il!! 'sa [aa $ Ull IPRIFI , II Il; I I I I . ji II»I I llUI IIII I%II I ~ I j!! I j!!!I i ill I I !j jib'l ]U ~ I Iil'hah jl Ill il 11 I I I I! i II I 'Il'Igi I 'Ilia ~ I, Is jiil! !IPi ~ j@f i jill I I Ql I I ,8 I I jam!/ I'lil iil ii! ai gll I SI aha, II Illa I II 'I ~ ' I''I I II III I I ~QLI' R I I ~ I Il a' l a I I I I I Ill I'. a I 5 ml I I I & IIIHH..H bl 1 — ==mwrr '-==,„,"!iiiiFIIL, I II%I as is '%11 IB.I li ill i%mimi" sin l I II IV Ii alla I'l I'Itn Ilk1iiji ~Igi I Illillnb asii il Il Ill a ~ ill i i ll iih itgil1IJ I j, '!II a ag i'I I I /i a~i' ~lwislll 1~1a1 g~ i~1/Ij ~1~ n s~mtftactssgiajassekmsaI~~+%III+~~'"aan~ie~mtauntt+4 sn ~glig Illa (II +@ma lllmlmlal @A,kliiIIIIIIillll ~1IRr ~ 11 I IA1K I Together we can change our world Iigauul I an n ms" I I I a l= *.= =. l ~ llslull ijgl l f111'i ilail N I IIBR l till/]ij i Decentrahized cooperation jlw ilIIIA Ililhll i, Kxrgerience with International Mnnicipai IIIIII Ii I I til 'IIII ~ uliii ii guilt I Ill I)! Ill Assistance Programmes lIllllll ilail By Patricia L. McCamey' IIlllltI illlll) Istll ill I I iilg II ~ 11 llllll t,iilgg ra es s Iii I 110 1 I I I I i Si B I I i a ~ I i aeag I I t fiIii i j -'-:-.,: I I allanlIII I I jl ip llml !I I ,'I i imiiII"NI ~ I a Ir-:"'I 1 I '1 iI1 ~ llg' I I I I 8 the Federation of Canadian Municipalities (FCM) was establishing components of its International Program, namely, of Canadian municipal the "Municipal Pmfessional experience and expertise. This „:."IIijs Exchange Project" and the "Africa 2000 Project." dialogue originated in the early In 1980s over deliberations on the addition, the FCM China tdea of Canadian municipalities Program was beginning to ~tip, II I I' p "partnersh:p" with Third the possibilities for investigate „"„„, „ ttm i I „; World cities. Many argued =;;;,; = =;. R linking Canadian municipalities IN, that the relative wealth of ign=,,;, with Chinese municipalities. nr I Canadian cities and towns and The question of the relevance the level of urban economic development in of Canadian municipal experience and Canada made the Canadian experience nontransferability to deva:loping country transferable and inappropriate. Others municipalities emerged again in planning argued that despite these observations, how best to execute these programmes. The certain key aspects of municipal sceptic s asked what a small town in management and technical know-how in Manitoba could possibly offer a municipality Canadian cities could be transferred and be in Central Africa. The supporters argued quite useful to their developing country that it was worth experimenting to find out. counterparts. It was argued that Canadian municipalities could also learn from their All three initiatives have been developing country partners in the process. launched (despite the sceptics) and are beginning to show very interesting results. This debate arose again in 1986 when Although it has been too early for formal During the past few in years Canada, discussions have been on-going over the relevance to Third World cities ', ~ I ~ ~ j il I ljII MI lI I I I I I ll l I'I I 'l I i I I I . II I I L1 II i ii IILI ll'i I ~ I~ ~ I II ''.".''." '.ll ~ I FEB-2 lQN III li I iii li St I Iiil I I III r III' 'atricia L. McCarney received ber Pb.D. at MIT. Sbe is currently teaching in Political Science at tbe University in the field of urban politics and planning in the Tbird World and is consulting to CIDA and the World Bank. Dr. McGuney bas recently been Director of 'World Cities and the Environment: The Five Cities Consultation Project" (1990-1992 and funded by FCM, CMHC and External Affairs in collaboration with the World Bank) the results of which sre fortbconung in a book to be publisbed December 1992. Dr. McCarney recently beaded sn Urban Sector Mission to South Africa (1992) to assist the democratic movement in the development of a national urban policy. prior to joining the University of Toronto, sbe worked at the International Developmem Research Centre 0DRC) in Ottawa for the Urban Development Programme, Sbe bss also worked in the World Bank in Washington (1990) and in the United Nations Centre for Human Settlements (UNCHS-Habitat) in Nairobi (1933-19S4). II III 'gp'lI, llif I I li I tl ll llfj I'l I II:= t lI..., „, IIIUpm I I4 I I I%ill IIII', i a=.,; ~, fill UIRIIR IIIU pg N 4 ~ lips a p II ! IIII4 4 IPgml I IA IJLII I I 'UIp I « 4 i llg ' U! ii mI ~ 41t'I I ill! lg 1$ $ I ss!aII '4 4—,, IIII 1 I I I ~4 I I m! 'il i,i iLI ~ I ~ ' CIDA is currently planning to launch an evaluation of the FCM International Program in recognition of the impact of the program to date and with a view to extending their support to FCM. This will include a review of FCM as a partner for CIDA in the context of ClDA's broadening program in the international urban sector. Without the benefit of this evaluation yet to be undertaken, it is nonetheless becoming clear that there are specific areas of competence and experience which Canadian puuniapalities can offer to their developing country counterparts and something of a "strategy" is evolving on how to operationalize the exchange, key aspects of which are outlined below. gi[ i.s STRENGTHENING 11 !IS, iUi ~ a ~ ir... .I tllS s IIIII m 'N I II!" tf4/!! I'I I!QI iI -'l I LOCAL AUTHORITIES I I I I I ~ i, I ~ I,', "salk 'IIIIII are your municipalities responsible for? How do they fund these activities? What rights do they have to raise revenues How did they come by such locally? powers? What is their relationship to the Who provincial level of government? collects garbage?" What is now becoming clear is that there is a wealth of experience in the process of how Canadians and Canadian municipalities have worked through these questions and issues. It is also clear that the actual arrangements may not be applicable, but the Canadian process and the institutional framework that supports this process hold great value (and interest) to developing country municipalities. As developing countries increasingly engage in this process of strengthening tht:ir local authorities, demands for assistance will likely expand and the FCM International ,81'N'l The sceptics: asked what.Ia :,small: town in Manitoba UIUIU 111'U 'mml, II &sr One very valuable set of urban experiences in Canada has been in the field of intergovernmental relations. The debate on decentralization and the sharing of powers with local authorities has been a long one in Canada with a fascinating history spanning some 120 years. In the various activities outlined above partnership s, municipal exchanges, and training of government officials from developing countries — preliminary experience has shown that Canadians participating in these activities are consistently asked questions such as: "What r IIII J II I I!I I I It I I III II I JII'rogram ttlf lit j)~ I --:.. evaluations on any of these activities, the early findings do allow for some insights and the dialogue/debate on the relevance of Canadian urban experience is becoming more sophisticated and is moving beyond Municipalities both simple scepticism. within Canada and the developing world are reviewing the experience to date and are ashng difficult questions and raising challenges with a view to improving future development. IUijil! ii'III IN = " ' 1::::-::: II = I Ill 1'!!I llllill I I il!mj( 'm mwlll'IIII I m Ill iw i I 1 ill IIII. . 'll'll'll' I could possibly'ffer a'municipality in Ce'ntral Africa.. Colombia has recently decentralized the sales tax to municipalities and attached new responsibilities to the local authorities. The Colombian municipalities could benefit by the extensive work in Canada on the process of negotiation and compromise that led to the sorting out of these powers and development of appropriate management systems. Colombia, along with Costa Rica, Ecuador and Peru, have been involved with FCM support in a three-year programmefunded by CIDA and a number of rnultilateral donor agencies. The programme, called SACDEL (for "Regional Training System for Urban Development and Improvement of Municipal Administration in 1 %4 I Office will be increasingly called upon to respond. Ill I I I I I ~ I P I I I I I I II 4 I ~ IIIII I I 'I ll I I I I I ~ '... '.'IU I a.. — ~N ia! ~ -- /tee '/It J'Jr: = -'-- 'I''::=-;iii,: hf!'= .—-„',""';==utggim'Bi@ J — - '~t ' -e HAJJ B I e - "-- ~ 1!iII I'IIRI ~:: - ss... i%I'!! "'ig! I'/' 1 jl iiilit '"-.r-.",IIIn!1(ldlII —: 1"u)1glll'n~ " &" htiij/ Jp I! Il'lI .— ~Iud — == ' ' &I I tan p emlaet! Js J s -MIk Ljlu~lll= ~Q IIBs1! smiiQM~JI5 fg/Il -'~,',5[I JnnmginJI',"„' Together we can change our world aaI I1 liII I Il ""I ""' I! Il~ J'I I! .e! Itt J(g'i iI~i Ill l "11J gll II IIII11 I ,~ii I ig! IP Latin America" ) has since 1989 held seminars, prepared training texts, and helped national institutions hold their own training courses for municipal administrators. As SACDBL illustrates, the Canadian urban experience can be a useful element in a comprehensive programme to help developing country municipal governments deal with decentralization. LOCAL GOVERNANCE AND PARTICIPATORY POLITICS 5 I!t l I I! I ! Si ! 0 Ill i t Js 1! !e fl!Il~ J IJ :-'- ="!III o. n '1! Another early finding from these activities is that there is a Canadian approach to local municipal politics and operations that is valuable and helpful to developing country governments municipalities. This has to do with the way Canadian local !I I I'I~II I 1 " !II! I! I'~ I '!ii II ' I i, i ~'~ I I organizations s management decisions. 4 'J! g 11'! ' t l 'I!I %1I » ~ Pl I I JIJ1! J!' ~ ae s n I in Canadian local governments, for example, hold project" 'Ariother.iearly. finding from tliese activities is that there is;a Canadian approach to local gnuriicipal politics and operations that is valuable helpful, to developing couri try muiiicipalities. 'nd . . into organizations It is this approach, in effect a political approach to local governance, is proving valuable (and often novel) to many municipalities in the developing I I '&i'll I mi I Jl 1 ilih'110 I n JJn !n I I'&& 1&1j its 'ill!I I I q and ihkih I 11 private companies m the Canadian 1W,r e, the community with counterpart community African in the technical partnership arrangement. R is these two Can'adian.localgovernments: political aspects of Canadian urban tryita,pereeiVe glObaly'Omthe long expenence: mu'nity nee'ds and involve on 'aeal Organ&gatiang in'Plan intergovernmental 'ning and.m'anagement deci- relations and power consultations on needs and routinely consult with interest groups, community-based organizations and the private sector before political decisions are taken. There is a well developed machinery involving committees, hearings, and special advisory groups which strengthens Canadian local authorities in their community relations. I ii tsiat activities partnership which involves local 'T/llS Aag tO dO With tAe Way 'hich 'e1,! ll! try to integrate community needs and involve local world. For example, in Latin American cities, there is a well developed and vocal set of community based organizations but a very low leve.l capacity for local Canadian governments to respond. experience is beginning to prove valuable in training and policy seminars in Latin America as a result of having built a municipal machinery to hear and try to understand the needs of communities as well as to then respond to them. The Africa 2000 Pmgramme has integrated a new component called the "community based IIJ Ii! I gI5 S I hl debate sharing arrangements in Canada as well as the political machinery to integmte participation and community needs into local government planning and decision-making that hold values for urban centres in developing Canadians are beginning to countries. transfer these elements of the Canadian urban experience in their work with Third World municipalities. I I I ~ il 'III 1 11ai 1111:ll u eii eis III iI Ill 0 I I V,: URBAN MANAGEMENT I Besides the political experience Canada is beginning to share with its which I 'i I [I%I J i xiii s IAP!ll Pl%I I IR .'l'& i 111 ) I ii I tU lii' nr Il 51 ! JJ .II J ill II ~ F&8-p et! s«s~~m~— — ~- — ~s=~ggnnlInla~ — ~ ilIIs "anl~na++~natllant. IIIN,—",,i IIII,;II II I!,Ii,!!!II 12 Federation of Canadian Municipalities partners in development there is technical proving a valuable ingredient in Canadian municipal assistance. For example, Canadian municipalities have in place efficiont taxing and biHing systems, good computer and information systems, and effective personnel management structures. The partnership activities of Canadian cities ! lli»III~I'! IIIII," I 'IIII' the identification of problems through technical exchanges where southern partners explore, in Canada, the approaches taken and the northern partners explore the same in the developing country municipalities and assist with advice in the sector. This style of cooperation and partnership is indicating that, unlike one-way systems of assistance and transfer of expert advice, this exchange model is promoting sustainabiTity in. the long term collaboration and support between municipalities in Canada and abroad. 'III) II II'Al I II III', II!IIIIII! !IIIIII Clkkll I«SSS SSI ill la IIIII STRRN ts THENING MUNICIPAL IiCM i«s IpeEE placed:tO aSSESt 'SSOCIATIONS in the': creattioii'' str«e FCM, through its International g: ofasso-: ing andfn Program, has facilitaml cooperation between c:iat:i..on:s:.':: of ..E.oc'ai Canadian municipalities and developing goi erriment;:: FCM .has: In addition to country municipalities. facilitating these exchanges, an important 'linked:. with:: the 'tEationaE: III i% ills'i rigtheri-'ctfontn IliiiIiP ~'„~ Ihll I IS I siIijll " ' I IIIR,,;,'ili'I I llfI I', II I .'.., ', l s 'I IIII S«S Associa«tion 'oof'LocaE"Anth-. orittesi in-.GIRJA'na (NALAG)to,.'hire.:in' "direct way It hat has beeri Ee'arned iri 90ey ear a'nd, reform:,.in Can 'istory'f its'debate «««1 I I I I fl I', s na iI It Sl « «I II ' I I I I ~ 's':«& il 'II)I ««&I (Ill knowledge through partnerships. Something of a th.ee step strategy is beginning to emerge, whereby Canadian municipal officials with a general raanagement background first meet with the linked municipality to jointly identify priority areas for assistance. The partners establish a work plan that is integrated into the partnership agreement. Depending on which priority sector is identified, technical experts from both cities having hand«-on experience at a macro level in the sector then work on role for the Federation itself, internationally, is becoming evident. In the majority of developing courtries, equivalent associations of local government are either non-existent or are very weak in both structure and performance. A need has been recognized by Canada, Italy, France, the UK and other industrial countries for the strengthening of local governments in developing countries. Part of this effort must be directed at strengthening the associations of local governments in these countries since much of the aforementioned task fies in reforming local central governmert relations, particularly with regard to financial and administrative arrangements. The associations provide an empowered voice vis-h-vis central governments to advocate for such reforms, make proposals for policy, and document the impact of national level programs and policies on local levels of government in a united fashion. I'lIII ! 'll I U MTti i II %I'I I +IIIII I,/ Ill I II I 'II I IIII I jllII II l! Ij! il 'lJ II'') t dIII ll I II g I III I II ttl 'II 1ll 'iI 'I I ~ I I ~ I C II I 1 II « I Ii I! III" tl «S . ! I ii « I« jj I &ISSS IS ' 1I I ILI ~ II «11 ~ I « I Illllll 4 I a~ ~et I 8 / !1 I I '.=.'.==- ~iggigggggggiImll —; ——— dlI-"" "NL8+ i 'Ill t 4 — 4 I II ' I I ia I Ilillllig(' E'Illllll 9 II I' tt 15 'I I l Ill /Ill IIIU l Illaal~g I ~ I 4 I I llkll% idyll „S/ laa I Jl!I la!! II Ill I Ilii ai i 4 1 ~il~ sl4 sl I 'ual44 4 aiiaiIL/ g'i" inly. I N Ill! g "'ll! I gt i I 4! l LI ~aimlll'!IIII )Ti!gal Ills, Ia III am@ II, 'I ttlll8 Ir ! I I I 4 I 311'I Given this identified need in developing countries, FCM is well placed to assist in the creation, strengthening and functioning of associations of local government. FCM has linked with the National Association of Local Authorities in Ghana (NALAG) to share in a direct way what has been learned in its 90-year history of debate and reform in Canada. It is this history and functioning of the FCM that holds valuable experience for the creation and strengthening of municipal associations in developing countries. An initial attempt to offer assistance by the Association is underway in Africa under the new Municipal Development Program (MDP). While the MDP generally is aimed at strengthening municipalities in Africa, one component of the MDP is strengthening local government associations. With funding from CIDA, the FCM is "contributing $ 100,000 to the MDP for assistance on the training and municipal associations component. It is inlportant that Canada forge ahead on this front and become a leader in this field, having FCM as a model for associations worldwide. Italy in fact has been seeldng advice from the Internationa! Program of FCM on how best to facilitate the strengthening of associations of municipalities in developing countries as well as a system of decentralized cooperation for Italian municipalities. STRENGTHENING ASSOCIATIONS 4'ositive 44 I II lli l! 4 I 4;;,;= si II PROFESSIONAL experiences have also been recorded by the Association des directeurs gdndraux des municipalitds du Quebec (ADGMQ) deriving out of FCM's Africa 2000 Programme. Cooperation, for Ir } I "ll ll4IIJg" nag!!I ~aggl~ gw'I'..~fl) ~ 'g — I Igg ll 4 fl lg! , IILi atu!i'ii IIIIIII the professional exchange of involved municipal personnel, a municipal environmental evaluation in the sanitation sector and direct community assistance. As a result of this initial activity, the ADGMQ has identified an important role for itself in Francophone Africa: the need for the strengthening of African associations of senior municipal officers through uaining II I I I'l III I I IIIII III I I The programmes have had a very'osiiive.. impact: on .:the Canadian 'unicipalities involved; parttrcularly ''!in terms, ' f'rofessional. growth. An improvement.in morale of Canadian municipal staff involved....,in the exchanges, and:.a. shiP. about. holv" their iccitl is beginning to be seen.::.,'. RL"'I KH ~ II I I%I 4 4 II ' I I4 IIll! I 'I IIII II II hill F ILK A I I I IRV Ii IR I II'! 15%IIIi I I I iigIIIL I I'4$ I 4u and exchange with the ADGMQ. The association has observed that Francophone African countries are receiving mainly European training and have inherited a European tradition of municipal management and local government from their colonial past. The ADGMQ is well situated to offer expertise and training from the North American model of municipal management and local goveniment. 14II Pl! I'mI ' P'4' 4 4',llt II I 4 I I I FEB I IL'll II' 'unctions: in'ttitude: 144 Iglmjgs ' ~~ "=::~j jii I'",;~-'"-~gggiaimui.. 4 ltmtttgm~gL~I~«l IIII'Ill'I"" Iliieel In& IIII!II san!tl t: 2 1993 II 4 II I I I ~ ~ 14 * ~ — ai 'II)g+tggeaFS~=='een~jelttr =:. ~, p = " — [~ l an,, ae ~ ~ e I aea Smltaairilj I" //Igm P ~ulitgg ~ ~ a---~ — cannel=;:=~lillmlmteirelunnRuÃP~IISIII -~ — - e~ae+gLj I'ne aZse~g naenaawi — III@ E ~jj ilihl Aljl'~&, g I-~i g @Ikgmgjg 5 IIIIIe~a=. =: ."..„/$ / Ilhjlggjjg~ I ill IFItnns ", ..'.l III Ij libyan.—..= [ ~je„.--'4 ~aii aet tg) (~) lg)i'ii nsdsltI goal li'I taS gLal I anl HW1 ll i+,e lite II 1 .i%1 ae II II I F i I 'i ill'IjlI i]III— jljlii, '— " lli 1'8 I I n e a e a ai Fl I — Fedeeunon of Canadian Muni eipolines As a result of this identification, the ADGMQ has commenced training activities with the same associations in Ivory Coast and in Senegal. The Association is examining possibiTities between the three groups, for North-South and South-South cross-fertilization of ideas and expertise. One of the key findings to date is the need in Senegal and in the Ivory Coast for assistance in organizing municipal associations and in providing training in urban management. i FIneealillew g[j ) 1$ "III'jgIII,lil/ ala I lie I lu Il 'I ~ 'I ~ I I Iil jII I II II I'a I IF I ll li Ie ~ Ie 1 ~ I 3 iS I.!.Ie ,I I fiji = =11I il ~ I%I il Li Iia iigui -.: %F jj Vt i eII '" . ' i 5 i', =: ")Ill t ililllj i e III III I I» I '931 I! II IIII" :11 I e Soinething by 'doing of-: 8 al. Dgjices Ii e 'i ethtft the 'e approach:by thee EC 'I, ) I " nt to recog-. aperient'to ijtlSD'1lÃPOrtft I I I II II ij DECENTRAILZED COOPERATION: DIRECTIONS FOR THE FUTURE These examples point to a body of Canadian urban experience at the institutional level which is proving to be relevant to developing country urban practice. It is also important to recognize that the experience to date has involved something of a learning by doing approach by the FCM International Program. Most of this learning is not yet systematically analyzed but likely will be as part of the CIDA evaluation. However, a few issues are worth noting at this preliminary stage for future work by the FCM International Program. For example, experience i: showing that the pace of the programming is fact and often out of sync with the developing country counterparts. Due to t chnological and particularly communication difficulties, often in the past, what had been programmed for. the first year, actually took three years to complete. This is particularly true in the case of the less developed African municipalities. In addition, some very critical questions are being mised which strike at the very core of the development task itself, by both Canadian and developing country counterparts who have participated in the FCM International Program to date. These questions have to do with sustainability, and the importance of transfers of knowledge and management approaches for effective development versus the more literal transfers of technology and hardware. It is being questioned for example whether the latter can really lead to development that is sustainable. The less literal uansfer offered under the International Program, for example having to do more with management styles and approaches in the municipal development field, and policy advice on local governance and decentralization, may offer a more appropriate exchange between Canadian and developing country municipalities and in turn lead to a more sustainable development in the long term. IIIIIII I 'll en III'ljl II I l I I I I [Ltd PH ~ I n! Also in terms of sustainable development, experience with the municipal exchanges and partnership agreements is demonstrating that the commitments are long-term. Whereas mayors change, politicians change and so do municipal staff, the fact of the protocol allows for the sharing of knowledge over the long term and mi 1 el Ie I I I I I'I'le pj's Illni jj nj i'l'ijlilI lej ~ II I '„''i &Ifj 'll Iee die a II II I Nil ill ii m W ~ hl I I I Together we can change our world jli!I!iis'iilg Ltj magiiggjgl III llLS IRK IN' ( ~ Ii!'ii!ji gi ll iiI1i»ll5 11 SIN IIII lligI aw u o r I I I I I hence the potential for a more sustained development effort. The exchanges thus not only assist on the "how" of municipal management, but also on keeping people working more continuously on issues This has through political transitions. development implications for sustainable assistance that are only now beginning to appear as a result of the FCM international experience. What is also becoming clear from the experience to date is that the programmes have had a very positive impact on the h Canadian ' Il!!,IIII!I" ji.'...lNllll L P$ 1 III 'll IRR IIII IIII lip'j Rl municipalities In adtittion;:some. very'' :crNcalr 'questions, are' being raised Ivllich- str'ike. at the'very core.. oJ the 'deve'Jopment: task. 'its'elf,; :by':both Cana'diaii: an'd. .develoPillg country coun'terpalrts whoi'have pai tici pated the:FCM;:Jlnternational:Program to date. . . involved, particularly in terms of professional growth. An improvement in morale of Canadian municipal staff involved in the exchanges, and a shift in atutude about how their city functions is beginning to be seen. Having worked within a developing country municipality, a broader perspective on managing one's own city is developed which has a positive effect on morale and professional development. In any event, this "decentralized cooperation" between Canadian municipalities and municipalities in developing counties is relatively new and much stiD needs to be learned, but the initial experience is positive and the effort should continue to be encouraged. FEB -2 1993 ~i IFJL'7 $ ~ mi~ ~'1 im '~i~~ ' ~1%6%iII~~ '-= =-:--" I I iii~I Ig~mk lwhn ~a ==,= =:-- ' 1 558%I ~ » ~1 --'-'I~II~wlWI~ ~='-"==-==" =- "ii 1/j II Ih ~ '%9Ii I a Ij'Ijm pgs' IR ~ I Shn.'ALGARY Together we can change our world IIS ACTIVITIES IN CHINA - AN UPDATE ll,llii i,,s! 1115'III j „ ill el e smtl II 1 I I I II 11- sitm at 11 f I nh n I I . &i Ig j I I g I II Illa'& '%l J l IIII I Sl I I ... IS LJIIII 'hindi'i MS I .I1 .IIII,l' la g 8 Iii J'' ""-.'i il' e I I IIII , mi 'll i II. I II i ~ I ~ s ' li 'I „,. ill%I'I I 1111 !j !II I I till I1 II I' Two years ago this document presented a story on Calgaryhs relationship with Daqing, China. The following article updates this story. In 1981, Heilongjiang, the Province of the Black Dragon River in north east China, became Alberta's sister province. The pairing was a deliberate choice based on shared interests including agriculture, oil, natural gas, coal and timber. Geography conditions were also and climatic compatible, strengthening potential for An product and technology transfer. American source has described this twinning as the most advanced and productive Chinese-North American relationship of its type today. The provincial level twinning was only a start. In 1985, the cities of Calgary and Daqing established a municipal affiliation. As the oil capital of China, Daqing - or 1Big Celebration" named after the festivities following the discovery of petmleum - has long been a purchaser of Albertan oil and Through a more formal gas equipment. link, both sides sought more than simply increased trade. The 1985 protocol between Calgary and Daqing anticipated cooperation and exchanges in industry, agriculture, science and technology, sports, culture, education, public and general welfare. Calgary delegated responsibility for the linkage to the Calgary Economic Development Authority (C.E.D.A.), Through;, a. more, formal lai'k, both:,Isides Isoughtj more. 'th a simrtly ir'er'eased trade. , A joint International Business Section. Commerce and Chamber of the initiative of C.E.D.A. promotes the City of Calgary, economic growth and development by attracting new industry and supporting the expansion of local businesses. I II I' IIIJ I 1 ' Federation of Canadian Municipalities The Federation of Canadian Municipalities, through the Municipal Professional Exchange Project and The Chinese Open Cities Project, played a significant role in developing this municipal partnership into a practical business success story. WATER TREATMEbK PROJECT In April 1987, the Mayor of Daqing a formal request to the City of Calgary for technical assistance. The water treatment plant servicing the Dong Feng area of Daqing no longer met the demand for potable water matle 'plt o q'"s ~ tb dt's not have independent resources to undertake projects. Large scale municipal projects are tendered out to private consulting firms. C.E.D.A. wanted to avoid any favouritism in promoting or selecting one Calgary firm over another. C.E.D.A. helped put together a group of companies with the skills and experience to carry this project from inception to completion and meet downstream equipment needs. The companies came togetl!er as the CalgaryChina Consortium. While it may seem unusual for competing companies to work together, the Consortium initially provided security in numbers, spread the risk factors of international work around and helped build a higher coBective The gftggrCd J'ftgg p r o f i I e. proud of their national; djtiadrigfgm award wuming water et&g&Fgb&g fjgg& gitti++g++ egg treatment plant but frg gg:~Pfg+d ~fgfifJPTO indu and , atrial residential growth this district overb urdened 'fjt in, dmcffV8'.CltineSe-Xorfh Amehad the Ti&+@ t'&g+fi&+gJI++ existing system. There was an immediate need to supply drinking water for the expanding, suburb and an additionrd requirement to iecycle industrial water in sufficient quantity for the oilfields. C.E.D.A. with the backing of the City of ,f ]m, I I gj/ reassured II !tel& II III Calgary The formal twinning relationship requirements. . I'gg &Wl'g I Daqing officials that ihe work would be cost effective and of high quality. WIIIUI C.E.D.A. applied to FCM for assistance under the Municipal Professional Exchange Proiect, funded by the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA). Grants were made to cover travel costs of Daqing and Calgary municipal officials participating in the project. Private sector members of the Consortium covered their own expenses or received grants under other federal government business promotion programs. made Calgary the logical place for Daqing to seek assistance. Calgary could offer the advice of specialists in cold weather technology and oil industry water At the time of the twinning, C.E.D.A. officials had considered ways of organizing expertise in response to reque"Is for technical assistance. Cities generally do involvement of 'I tmn II I wsu I! I II »la I III I .:- '. 5 I fioI all Illa 41'& I I I il I ''=: II ~ ~ I 'I In i I g/ol 1 l,g I, l I il:..: .::!s II tl ~ i I f',Rg I i 'I( s ~ I ~ II ns,lit i Nhl' ~ I I I ,';='; nil 4ti fl .III'i4i, 'III An initial exchange of visits confirmed the need and the Consortium's capacity to respond. A prc-feasibility study ~ I u I m» ace ~ . I ~ I o I IU lit I I I Il!I utl ii 1I ""'ii/I! I Together we can change onr world I 1I II I was required for a new plant to nieet Daqing's existing and anticipated needs. Ijlllj lNIIn ll!14 jI&l jII I'!IIiR'Ill international IliiiII negotiating arranged downstream benefits for the Consortium with Daqing. Several other Consortium engineering firms lent experienced staff to work with Daqing staff in Calgary and in China. In February 1993, Daqing and Calgary will officially open the water treatment plant. Through these public and private alliances Daqing benefited from a new water treatment plant, while economic gains were realized. CAIA+ARY'S OTHER PAKTNERSHIPS IN CHINA IIIII III il I I '41 I I", I I II I 'hjltIil . jill'j'4 il ']II Ii'lP'I II'jl l 114 ~ CIDA-funded program I I ! ilj! 44!!! L I! I jl I!4i agreement to do a World Bank project feasibility study for a water diversion, treatment and supply scheme for Changchun. this triangular relationship which will focus on the exchange of technology, serrlces and hiow-how which will be beneficial to all partners. For Calgary municipal linkages have FEB-2 19l8 1 44' I I IN 4e! I I nIIIII Ill I e: —.;;::jr ]%I jj! Il I I I IIVI III! I, I!gs ls'IssIi f, illn4 II W!5 8 ~ I Ij fi IIIII, II'i IIj 4 41 IIin i'l fil lli ins»lst a III I M ~~ IIIII I I ii I 4 I ill! j[ illll." III n rl I n J 4 jlh 14 is 4 4 18 ~ II1 Ilail l Sea C.E.D.A. is now seeking support from FCM or External Affairs to develop a ilfI IJ In 1991, the Chinese Open Ciries implemented by the FCM International Office, suppo~ a delegation of 13 Changchun officials for a three-week training program in Calgary. At the completion of this program, members of the engineering consortium signed a $ 3 million 4 I pride.. Early in 1992, Calgary began exploring a relationship with Tyu men, Russia. Tyumen is a Siberian city centred in the Tyumen Region - the second largest oil producing region in the world. Initial discussions have focused on potential cooperation in thc oil, gas and environment sectors. Tyumen currently has a formal relationship with Daqing and the possibility of Calgary joining a triangular relationship is being explored. Project, I . catalyst for a range of economic and social aciivities. tliat have forged a solid relationship. Investment of time an d money are paying off in 'ways in iwhieh:all sides'an take 1990, officials from Daqing introduced C.E.D.A. to their counterparts in Changchun, Jilin Province. The City of Changchun required extensive work on the upgrading of the potable water supply and treatment works and the wastewater collection, treatment and disposal works for the City of Changchun. Daqing officials, very pleased with the work of C.E.D.A. and the China-Calgary Consortium, brought C.E.D.A. and Changchun officials together. In 4 For Calgary. municipal linkages'have served as a Engineering agreed to act as project manager. On behalf of the Consortium, UMA applied for and received funding from the Industrial Cooperation Branch of CIDA to conduct the pre-feasibility study. C.E.D.A. officials experienced in iim III1 I lf'I I'l,I'1!'llljL jl's II I gl I I ' ~J'.!5'~— = )Ng'-'-ni¹.~=, 'ill till =--~m M=s W J1IRR nil 8'lj I IIIIIIII I~JNL'il 20 Fedeeanon of Canadian NunieipalNee I'/)/ 8'l 1% I! li IIII served as a catalyst for a range of economic and social activities that have forged a solid relationship. In addition to economic benefits for Calgary there has also been a range of friendships developed and prospects identified for future work. Investments of time and inoney are paying off in ways in which all sides can take pride. !~~I 1N I I 1 I Ii ais seine ll IS l SI I RT R I 4'IILI) , JJillll iei,i,L4 '14 IS I IJ si Jillli g ."'al ~ 'l 11 i'ill II a I ~P 44: I I I I ill 4 I I I I II I Ill IIIIII IIII L4 I I,II I lllii I lisle I Iig I 1 ~i il i I s Ij Illnss di~a ~~~fggsRMRI --m!: $ 16~- m~ Is tii litItj — I%+II ! ~g iM SS II 1$ I I a F IS% I gL ''''' ''''S "''.'",6) I/I h I I I I I II I I It I Together we can change our world 21 0 LI!I6 lr I II[~" gj llltlill 1I . I I II II I N Ills uj t ILIIlj g tI 'I j,l6 I'I i ll I /Pl f t Hi —- SAS~ mON-GRENADA il jI gIill.l 11 II63Ij CANADIAN WATER METERS IN THE ANTII.I.ES litt l t I I I I UIjl» 5 ljlikiII&ii I I 6 iiiiiij I/nil s I P h $$ 8 Ilsa I I Il I ~ II I I ', &l I I I Ii tl I I t I J I II&, jI Igni i iuI I',iIjI, I ;-„';.:-; s6 II I I II l%tl I II" iII'i I gl I r, III! IIi i II'i'~ I6I Recyciing and international aid: Saskatoon has killed two birds with one stone in her link with Grenada. The Prairie municipality has not only provided very tangible aid in the form of a water supply for a smaU Caribbean island, but has at the same time succeeded in recycling thousands of water meters otherwise destined for the scrap heap. Besides this lack of control over water consumption, at times of the year, Grenada faces severe shortages of drinking water. ct~ Ijj II Ig I I I' ii g iiI t IN II li5 &e ~ S 'll ,'I III t I uJIU' 66 I THE NEED FOR METERS I i jiti For Grenada, the need to solve this water supply problem became even more 'ji" IIII The water supply system in St. George', the Grenadian capital, is composed of many small surface water treatment plants and several drilled wells. The majority of the city's residents are connected directly to the water mains. Although industries and businesses are serviced through water meters, the 15,000 homes in the city are not. I POnr relation ": with,: tlt people of'Gree ada're excellent, says '. Vere Dyck, adding,:,'.We have regular telephone'ontact, .and. they hat e become real friend. When we visit Grenada, we are treated like roy- IS I . 'l flI I I I I 'IIIn Ills II I I I I II I SKI .: ., I I . II urgent when foreign aid agencies stated their intention to freeze aid for water supplies EEB i Ri I1 I I " I, i-':I ii ". . Since residents are charged a fixed rate per hookup, the municipality cannot measure water use, control wastage, or even monitor illegal hookups. In some particularly poor neighbourhood s, up to five families share the same service connection, sharing, at the same time, the bill. j -2 1993 'I ~ i/~ '~I i a ESI lsaniin j )Itii. ne 0 ll Ilti IPi i Li~nllll'a ;; lsw I t I i5 am IP a~ ill!e ewe~ ~ll ss ~ -=--"~no '55 ~IIII~ ,'Ilgi gill ir W — limml l I i14 II I I Inurn I nn] I '"'"" It 511 --"---="'-"-.'- I ll 'l II,' J nl I i Sl I It i I I 'IVII Ill I I t JLi11 ii ',;.'" all iiIi Ii'Il, 22 IIIII Eeaesrnson o/ Canadian Nnnieipalilies ll 'iisl ~Q I I I I I II I ' 'f&itI'i I II Ilail I, t' II II1! Ill' ILI Ill 1'III LI fjllillL,I 1' ill I'i'I system." This was the context when Saskatoon decided in 1990 to link with Grenada under the Municipal Professional Exchange Prograin (MPEP). The need was already defined. Canadian municipal managers would give their St. George's counterparts the benefit of their experience in water supply systems management. Studies have shown that there will be a notable differei ce in water consumption when users receive bills at the end of the month. "When people have to pay for water, they are conscious of every gallon that comes out of the tap," notes Vern Dyck. IR I Saskatoon decided therefore on support for preliminary studies and system planning, technician training, and technical assistance for the installation of 2,000 meters as a pilot project. 8 I [i a.'a a visit to Grenada in 1991, Canadians inspected the proposed project sites, revised regional maps, and inspected service connection sites so as to determine the type of meter needed. two ~t 11LI Lll I I I al I I 7 II i I lllIIII IIIIIII Ig Lilt li I Pl&l LRIII A PROtECT ON WHEELS iii'ii IIIII 't tnli4 i Isis ln October of 1992, two Grenadian III gal I The Prairie municipa'lity has'ot only proviChd. very tangt;bie. aid in the form of 'a,:water supply fsor a smail::Caribbean island, but: has at the same time succeeded in recycling thousands of wafer meters otherwise., destined for the 'scrap: heap. .II illL p i'i st l I I I I I I I I I I (II[ij . I I I Ilk I'uring [I illtRIiaa ii e Al ~ Rlts~n4 until the delivery system was improved. II I', I'0 I H&&li EDMONTON METERS RECYCLED II'ii'atrll -. ill i s t ii ie IL I ~ I i: I I! i II I I &RIi if li f ''t I . i II I lj! I I I&srlI I I li I I Saskatoon's greatest coup came during the search for meters. Fortuitously, Edmonton was completing an exchange of all its water meters for a more modern, rapid, accurate type of meter. Edmonton agreed to donate 2,000 old water meters for use in the Grenada pilot project. Vern Dyck, Project Manager for the City of Saskatoon, explains. "Most of the meters are in good or excellent condition. They only need testing and reconditioning before installation. There are 15,000 system connections in the St. George's network, and the goal is to install 15,000 meters. Not only will there be a major savings of water, the additional revenues generated will allow the municipality to improve its water supply ~ ~ -;:,:= IiIl Jl IIP III II Ill I ! municipal employees trained in Saskatchewan, learning how to recondition, test and install water meters. The next step, sending 2,000 meters for the pilot project was funded by MPEP. Thanks to Edmonton's contribution, there will be sufficient meters for the entire St. George's system. Once the 2,000 meters are installed, more will be made available each year for only their value as scrap, from $ 2 to $ 4 each, to be paid by Grenada. ! I ~ ~ I l ' Rt I llwtla) tt I ~ R RR u i~I== R&mlg~= = '~ssataa —.— NSII; = e 'Allnght — 'INNE IMRIt Innas malI ~NIR«RRRRIRIWRIRlllllgn«t ISS! IRN =-= ~ R att a a IN NI I I I ~I«g lmt ~ Nt) I N Ih ejgiil [I aata a 11 I N I 1 ~I'll IIfllij,l I II 5 SR ml' nl Ia IN I I I S I I I I ~ I ) I R lllal L I g It nt Nl I I Together we can change our world I l I 11i I j j jill«II I l,ig .—.. t==.. Il IIII II I II lli t I I, I fj,jg I 4. 'AI%ljN Iniiillgl Isj 'S ISRRI I Jljl IIR I I If@ t lt Ilrlt To date, the project has been moving as if on wheels. The Saskatoon municipal employees 'have gained insight into old problems viewed in a new light, while the Grenadans are overjoyed to have found a solution to their water system improvement problems. "Our relations with the people of Grenada are excellent,a says Vem Dyck, adding, "We have regular telephone contact, and they have become real friends. When we visit Grenada, we are treated like 23 Ihlll%'JIJ The Saskatoon municipal employeei'ai e',gmiied; gnsgght gnto . g liig g «I, 'n«l 'I 'old.ppro'blems, I viewed:,in,.:a:ne'w :'.Eigh w'hile: i'Ae.:: Gren)i~ans" ar overjoyed:to. harv'.e; fou Iln'III $ I s I t a:solution to: th 'system improvement pro- 'll/itIR R Il blems." royalty." III ~ II ~ 5 II I II I e: El::.nl tI I z t.'ai I -'' I If'ia.il I I i ] I'. I ~ I lt ii ntia . t I IIIIL II gi III I [I lti 'tt)ll )I ta Although the project was conceived as a technical exchange, Vern Dyck believes that Saskatoon gives more than it receives, at least on the technical side. On the human side, however, the experience is a rich and valuable one. Dyck adds, "It is an extraordinary way of travelling for the people involved in the project, to learn and to discover another culture." III tn I I I 8 ill I I 'IIII I!' IR Ills II I I I l5)t'I III I E.:.: I g;;;.; jilt =,~ I ) I L I l R. ii I IIR e I I I I t I I III)I II I I IIII I I I I I II I)t I k I lt I ) ~ II jgj[ Iil I I, I 'I 'l II ii I "ttl II l Ijkililli I ~ tat '' I R I I II t 4 I I I' I I I a a ~ I I lit t)t I I '1 a t~ ) I FEe -z ]ggp 14 a~ Itua i , I Rwi iwli IBBilsss I, i.": II O'S — = I ess ~ .~n i -===- — II =— ! "i u e4s I IB I I & ueil ) I — I—: :i1% ~ j, jg IN g j '| ~~ ¹I m n MP~~~ I 0 ' 4 I t vl ' ( I jI II Ilisi IE ~ Il'II ill lg I i . ~ Ii 4-::: 2tl III ll IB eli o I et 'I Ii a !Is 4III 'IIII I il Il i I 25 Together we caa change our worhf 'i II kl 4I ll i I ' I Ii'l 4IIill II gl Ilerii '/I iitgj oui i i Ill- 'I g IILI Ifl g Ill/I I I lii L'j I II I III! I ..: 1 I/ /// /'//J-' '&x ':/'. t~'e;.-8'"O' e I -I'- L:. '"1/r /."-!:Iv I v s''L' L' 'I i "IS 7 ut.t'I 'I' .I'- I \ 'I 'I ii'I »~ / LJ~ I //////'XNAN I'III IH, I 'I III III II i '4 II4, I I II I ii i!!it il III I llj I, Ii I I I I l I I Iir J II ~ II i'l Ia lkii 11 iii il i!i il Ie i ie I 1st ii u II a Ill ~ Ii i I So as to meet such basic needs as a clean water supply, Mzuzu was forced to tl4''tjNi j'i 1 I I the "Approximately 90% population of Mzuzu lives below the poverty line, with no access to basic services," says Bryan Baxter, Town Manager of the Municipality of Cobourg. Be has worked many volunteer hours on this link and has visited Malawi twice already. of iS ' III With 15,000 inhabitants, Cobourg, a flourishing municipality near Toronto boasts an annual budget of $ l5 million, while Mzuzu must get by on $ 3.5 miLion for its burgeoning population of 70,000 and its annual growth rate of 10%! i realign its organization and financial structure. As part of the Africa 2000: The Municipal Response program, the African town, with the help of its Canadian counterpart, had set as its target the improvement of its general operations. " The task was immense, and after countless discussions and consultations, the municipal managers were forced to settle for a threefold plan targeting etigineering, management, and computerization of finances. ';~i~jllj I II !i all h'ave common problems, such as the environment, 'which can only .be resolved on a global leveL.,TA'e.'more:we work toge'ther,:the better, are our. chances ofsresolving these issu'es and the ,better are our .chan'ces for. worldpeace. We AND I I I ill 'll li . DRAINAGE ~! I I I!M I II l i 'I II II ~ I ~ s 8 I 4ll i 'l'I IIII" II;;L; .—=,. h ii I u I ~ ~ jg" "" 'll'I 11144 4 I IIIII SI1 ~ R ptii iiii I I /]( I i II FLOODING I gl II IIRI I, Ii ill! . Ill glh ll gi i Ig'EB II jlfII, II4 II f!$ s is 4~I!t ~ ill! ~ SS ':S What is the one similarity between Cobourg, Ontario and Mzuzu, Malawi? Both towns are expanding rapidly. What is the difference between Cobourg and Mzuzu? The state of the municipal treasury. l /mj ~„~,sLm~ S Sos:-'"'': s ttlw" I:.I ':i. Il II 'SIS llllk, 'I Ii'ilnl II I I'l i Il%4 44 oil I I ~, i'e ~ PROBLEMS Mzuzu, located on the slopes of the Viphya mountains at an altitude of 1,200 ll ps 1I -2 1993 '. I i ~ I /g R ''.Illle ~ R IIIIII I I/ ILIRIHIIS ~ n~-~ ~ ~ ~: m4R R n 4 R1 ~4pl z g ll 5 I I! Ill I III 'l|tI il) Lh IllRIIR 41I ! I Ii"-", ~ 1 let ~ 4R4 .4 S Illtia! i. I 1R I44i ~ IllwIII,L iI Federation Rf Canadian Municipalities 26 I iilIII5 I IUIlj IIII lII I:IIIII ,g1 IIR ~ tun I — —. metres, has a rugged profile. The hilly relief is partly responsible for the disordered growth of the town, and is behind Mzuzu's drainage i problems that come with the seasonal rains. IIIIIII,'I I 4g 1 I ~ I I Ii I RIRRI I 144Iii g 41 ~ R ~ I 4R 44 ~ 4 I Jim I II I I 1 I I III) III I~ 141.*= nl'I Il 1LII I Is Iln as h of 1991, of the roads main the three In M I IR 4RR ~ town were made impassable by flooding. On their fust visit to Malawi, the people from IIIi ,Ihi Ire 44 R 41 II III III l'II III I I II 'l.l 4I I I ~ 4 itel Cobourg 11 I 4414ist 4 Ii Id'rf I 11'I gg 11 !'.! .':-',l'i 'll = R I I I - 4 .'nil On the administrative side, Canadians and Africans reviewed the organizational structure and the management layout for Mzuzu in a search for the system which would most efficiently supply services to the citizens. This initiative spawned a review of job descriptions, of the organization of II personnel, of employment policies, and so 1 I 4 I I II ~ l'IIIIIIII I I% IRIII II I'IIJSP/! 'I! ' il I Isis g I s' I II 1 1I I 'I Ilii ii ii I I I4, 1 fI 4ll 'till ti Itl I ''l 4 Ii%51 1% Ical I ~ 4 ill I The practice of monthly reporting preparation of agendas and minutes the and of Council meetings were instigated, and the holding of regular meetings of the management team began. S III I '":I 44 therefore the community project of the linkage: a footbridge built to link two To improve the finuncioi gide,.Mzuzu decided to enter tIge computer age. ~ II ' ()g@ concentrated their work on pairs of the town dunng th» stony season. rainwater management, as well as on the creation of little cost: the lack of comm unica non a development plan for Mzuzu. between employees of different departments could be remedied. ' 'tli11 J I I lI III, I LIKE CHRISTMAS MORNING ~ I ~ R .~ 4 II R R4 1 To improve the financial side, Mzuzu decided to enter the couiputer age. Along with his Canadian colleague, the Treasurer of Mzuzu established a list of priorities for computerized eliminating accounting, gradually slow and inefficient on. Rpencilwork". The participants in this exercise found that it was possible to correct one r..ajor weakness in the Mzuzu system at "On our second visit to Malawi, we arrived in Mzuzu at the same time as the computers. At the Treasurer's office it was I III t I, I II I PJJ 1 I 4 4 4 14 4 I 14 I I salt~ S&SS Asal IIS sI I Nwl I 4S 'I Ig siiiei isl fil I'III I I iil g PP ~ 1 II I IIII I I I I,l PPINI 4 IS IP i i i i' i Sl „~ ~liil IN/ I g I lsi i i!i ~ N I I 'I snl I g Illa II I I Ii i iill I liiiiii" like Christmas morning for them," reminisces Bryan Baxter. IIIilIi ectgsgt 'i-.~~N," training iIII AII LI III I I II '-il I II I "II,I0 5 I lli li '''IIISI il. I I Ill'i Iiiijj( atlit ii ii i 'sa Il I''IS I I till Pl Ia IP 11 I I i PS I I I I Sl aN I Pl Sl Ig I Sl I g i@ li I I 4 I li ji) I I The topography of Mzuzu Mayor and muni cipal staff with Angus Reid, Mayor of Cobourg, Mzuzu forces residents of tnaugutssttng the new well built through the linkage in replacement of the more distant suburbs to a water hole fphoto below). cross several streams and swamps to get into town. entire communities. For these reasons, In many cases, logs serve as rudimentary Cobourg and Mzuzu decided to centre the bridges. Frequently, people, often children, community project on the construction of carrying wood or food are injured crossing three pedestrian bridges on strategic routes these makeshift catwalks, During the rainy leading to the hospitals and the schools. season the water sometimes covers the roads, making them impassable and isolating "Apart from these footbridges, we also dug three surface wells for drinking IIII jj I III! 4' II II population II~ II~jiIII, *- P water. P~1 4 l,dIIPIII fll i!jill lljl II il~ IIII I III i I as 4&U &iiii BIi 1 Illll 4 Il! II'H.III I Ili I, Ili I I tinattliliÃ~~ljiiymfil~~l1~ pf N 1 II II 1 I 'a'jhjII ,'1! ISSI The benefitted PI Jl Sl greatly, but many more footbridges and many more wells are needed. It was only a drop in the ocean," remarks Baxter. 0 I Ill I I "'.! 11 I I rl Although conscious of the size of the problem, I I the 'he PI I Canadians sl I are II . '''n ~ I I 'ii ~ SPP PSS— IIII UP Il ~ PI R.'IIP FEB - ts Igg3 IHISI sf ill'4 P II ~ I I I II ' I ' 1! II Il 5 I ISIS! 1 'I P' I iiI IiI liII I nonetheless satisfied with progress in Mzuzu to date. "At first, being a North old water hole II II I '1 1s1 1 i I iIILil fk II ~ BRIDGES AND WELLS Inst! ,IIII financial management. ' I IIii»ii I~p and administration and I 11! LID I g !I!II'I On their second technical exchange to Canada, in April 1992, the Mzuzu managers expanded their qi I lllilLI knowledge of engineering, !i PI!111 I IIIIIIII 'I Bl ;..',", I S SIR I S S PIS I I ' 27 Together we can change our world 1 I 18%!I', I gl I i IS I j'llill I, II I I PS: tl « ~ I I I ~ I j $ 11 I I I 5I I I i ~ I I I l \ '(fill l isaanl II IS ill Ii III.':I ..;;. II i i I I l j jllI li JI,SeP j I ssi , li Il Jill nl la Ili I mafll II IIII ) I1 I I „ll an iaa 111111 ill'j IP "I:::. 5I I 's's II Sedeasnan of Canadian Nunioipa!Mes 28 II 0 i III American, I anticipated more progress, but I hsd forgotten that African culture is different, that they don't have the equipment to work with. All work is done by hand. In African terms, they have made tremendous progress," adds Baxter. Baxter mourns. IKJI1i g Ij la%i j11 I I I and if the Mzuzu-Cobourg link continues to .: '-:;,ll ~a ~ l' II IIII Ii~ I ll ill ii a aa g I I oaii I flourish, important progress can be made in the next few years. To date, the link has met with approval form the Cobourg Council and with the utmost support of the 1 IIljiiii in j I S I I III ii S Ii I 11 ss ij I I I 1~ I'4 l ii iaa I II ~ Ia !all ll li 'I a I sl h III , ' .s IIIII I Ml I ":: ' S S ~ I lla i Iml I M I las ss ~ Il " I II% S IljII lHI,IU jj'IIIII mayor, Angus Read. Even Cobourg's i il I INjll R Bryan Baxter sums up the link. "Cobourg gains two important benefits from this link: first, the cultural exchangeappreciation for other cultures, and second, participation in the global community. We all have common problems, such as the environment, which can only be resolved on a global level, The more we work together, the better are our chances of resolving these issues and the better are our chances for world peace," 'I "They are extremely anxious to improve the standard of living. They are very open to new ways of doing things, but many of the things we can help them with they don't have the money to implement," Rome was not built in a dzy, though, f citizenry has demonstrated its approval. Community representant Laura McCraken collected $ 10,000 in less than three months for the community project. I II 1II jjtilllI 'mll, II mal I,II'JILJJ i 5 I R lg I Il I I I lllll ill f I IIl li i,l 'r II I I III II III $ lass la ~ ~ SI la ~ I ~ II IIFI i Sill I 11 S Ill I l I I iIl I I I ll II ll f I I'I I I II, I„~, I o 'Illj I''Il'll I I I'ii 11% lllj ~ ahll ii I la su I g l l a I i s,as Sl ~ I I I ' :: '' I I na I s~sl I III RRIRiiiIiai ill I I $ I 1 118 $ ~ 'il O'I IIL 29 i, II)II II I IIII II s na III[1 ALcVA-BOGAM3E lllll ill HELPING IIANX)S BETWEEN LAC ST-JEAN AND GNAGNA IIII1III ' li 1 WVSI l IISaaa II I aa1 ~ s re.rr/'rsrs rs s KN+ .'/aero srsr..a": aO.XI I t XXYX .Srsr Nf. Is tt I/III @V.:.".-s l„eiiijl III I'ls Bls Is les Bl saa/elR ig 1 il Vll limes RI II RIB IlllII ll' le /8111 li IRII IN IIII 1 II II"S "s II II ' iuss III Ils I II+ 1I I I 1 ill I 1 i II I Ill ll I ss~I ~ Is il I" I I '«ill I '= il ! BII R Ill li I I I 1 'i i . vr.r rrrr~ II iII, I it', 'lus;we/1 I BI - — I'lIIR II semel . Jean-Claude Lusinchi, Director of GnaGna an exotic name for the Urbanism and Socioprovince where nestles Economic Planning for the small African town Alma explains. "We of Bogandd, linked with "Ear the Jflugg'tetptJIity,, a wished to provide Alma, Quebec. This direct aid, person-todesert reoion six hours person. We had the be- charice to do lust tlils 'The: E~iggrg tu Jgcti with Bogandd, so that :ca'use City"Ha@ heusesIJeoti is what moved of isolated parts +ie ~~h&'ar'e .cgtflggjgitte'ds municipal politicians. ''.Nggder7iiges Gerliais I.'Heu here are easily People tragically because they mobilized, developed. can see the results. They can see that the Parched by aid is getting there and that it is effective." endemic drought, stifled by tl'e absence of resources and infrastructure, plagued by omnipresent poverty, Bogandd was facing NO ELECTRICITY. NO TELEPHONES disaster. In this context, a link with the Town of Alma in the Lac St-Jean region was From a municipal management point greeted with jubilation. of view, everything in Bogandh needed u:,. s~n. The needs were great, but first Thanks to the development projects d'Alma, Alma m.t nad tn talk, not easy in Bogande, where of the Centre de solidaritd there was no electricity, no telephones. knew of GnaGna's crying need and was pleased to provide financial aid and was "Bogandd has only just installed its especially gratified to see the impact. first and only telephone, and I am a bit Largely for this reason Alma became afraid to call, because who knows where my involved in 1990 with FCM's /IPica 2000 call will end up!" laughs Jean-Claude Program. Jl ":!,'! I — -'... B-.a-.A~'e 'Sais~& l l 'l 'l ill .'::4"en+BR:s'3'-'ai-aae's& I l I i i /ii ..%78: O r I. "Searr . -, '.~W/I / / / M Wllllf I l.l LLI)I Together we can change our world f lII Ilail)'IIll ttt I ! 8 511 i II' flll7ll il I I'll] I ss I a I I I a IIIII'il I " I I I I I IN I Impel Ill Il 11 llll 'I ~ III I Bl I I ' I ll I I III 'I I II I IJ I II I' P.' I I II ~ U II I I FE8 see il 8% IV='I s iBIS ~ II —'I as I I I I I~ 2 1993 i I R Sm a n W 5 Wllm 1 1 sa ~II ~ st Rlil Ig'SI S I il llhl Illa ill I I= .' S ISIS s, ' ~ ~ I ~ sss~s I p IS! I I sl IK ~ ~ ~T lnn i In ~ lit taT,. 1 raI i l: 'N~gj IfIPrah , ' ,=in@1% 'Ia - ~ II ~ I ~ ~ I Ian I I a ilaiiiil i'Ill ) S u I il Isre - ~ nutli /$ [gin lm'Ila i ',;;,. I f I I i'l I 30 5 II, I jmm I lt't Itt Federation of Canadian hfunicipa.Mes f gf I Ifis= =.'=lI'1'I jj'IIa a IS Illa I le llu I 'Ill%'I isIi' ii l ' I II I I =='1lm I Celebnations for the opening, in April 2992, of the Women center built through the linkage. ,':=.„,,I I,ll ~ II I li a' I Lusinchi. Happily, communications between Alma and Bogandd were eased by the presence on the ground of "Save the Children Canada". "We can count on them. They give us technical support during our stay and manage the pmject monies." explains Gervais L'Heureux, Municipal Councillor and Director of the Centre de solidarite d'Alma. if[ 'lrii c.. IIIi tII stag a II I IIII li I ii iilfl 5I ruii isN. ffml l I. I On an early visit to Bogandd, Alma r III I llalll managers held exhaustive talks with their Burkinan counterparts, with a view to prioritizing needs. First and foremost was the need to acquire equipment to assure basic services. / I ii'i,'f For drainage works, they bought ill II I shovels, picks and wheelbarrows. For administration, chairs, desks, cupboards, filing cabinets, typewriters and calculators. All purchases were made in Burldna Faso so as to ensure some economic benefit for the country. ~II II si'I II I ~ l I'i, I As Jean-Claude Lusinchi notes, "We wanted to get them electric typewriters, but of course, without electricity, they wouldn't have been very useful. looked I everywhere for manual typewriters, but you can' buy them anymore in Canada!" MICRO-BUSINESS INITIATED FOR BOGANDf WOMEN As technical part of the exchange pmgram, the two towns centred efforts on urbanism and public works. During a recent visit by Alma town managers, road works and drainage were studied, as well as a model for municipal toponymy for Bogande. The community project part of the linkage saw Alma collecting the necessary funds for the construction of a women' social centre in Bogande. FCM then provided twice Alma's contribution. This project is now completed, and boasts equipment for sewing, weaving, embroidery and knitting. As well as forming the town's social core, the centre has spawned a microbusiness for Bogandd women to improve their own standard of living and attain some measure of financial autonomy. Thanks to the professional exchange pmgram component, a Burkinan visited Alma for several weeks, worldng at the Alma Socio-Economic Planning Office and learning cooperative management methods. ! l II I I I I , 'fIIIjl ggt I'I l, tilfi jl I Iff IIL,I I' I I'I I lllill I a al I II ilqI'I' Irtl I I I I I II (II II III a ll llf l I =:: s ~ ~ a aa '' I ~ I ~ baal ~ I ~ RS aII~— I I I II: = ili Mila a I I I ill II I I I 11(lilIIS ii r Ill el I I =—. l I rl 4 ui I ~ I jjjgg III I I I 4 Pl ~ zji / ~ '/u spill I m IPI P PP III P c ~ 14 I I p ~ 4I jji sirlijEIN &im„=.E... 1'saaPaIII j4 Pllll 41 «' i ij a g injsl I ~ l 111 Immmj elWW W— «mi! !Illy aI j I!Ijll!II«= -""'~&"" I ''4 ii~iiamtil gail~~l~gg P Pl I wu Pt 'll ll & 4"l '',ll'i II $/ 1444 4 Illll IP ~ Ii I g " «! jII' g MEN!NgaiuSI/ fjsm ''I I.llgII II IIPI! I lilti/'& gik! 'I Irlillfl i i Ill 1 'i IPP I ~ I I i Together we can change our worM 4 IL&& t IIIII I I IP I I gg ,illa''l' flm One of the primary stated goals of the project is "Muuial understanding between the two N s II %II'I communities". Alma is conscious of this, so, an important public awareness initiative was launched. II II 'll ll I I 'I I II! a!1 % IP u ~ I I'P" 'l / !bi I ,,IN! Pll ~ I ' I 'I II I I I' I I ~ it Iii I I ~ iii: g I 4 ~ &1! I Gervais L'Heureux remarks, "When the four Bogandans came to Alma on a technical exchange, they did not go unnoticed. They helped raise public awareness; one did the cycling tour of the lake, and the other three hosted stages of this tour." .ej.'~ Ties of friendship have been forged, clearly showing the spirit of cooperative assistance that characterizes this link. municipal managers on exchanges are always integrated into the social and family life of the village. ~ Ii I PP P 1 I I I "For the municipality, it's a doorway to other cultures. The link functions well ~~lC~=-=-=- W h e t h e r Quebeckers go to Burkina, or Bogandans come to Quebec, II pi tj, illl I I m 'lII I publicizing the HUMAN .!I .=: III I Bogarid&AIma link, and at the same time, raise funds. In 1992, this event drew Zx-Mayor of Alma, M. Nicol Tremblay, with Bogandi mayor and over 300 participants and municipal skiff during the inNal visit in Bogande in June 1990. raised $ 14,S00. W~ '! IIIIIII The bicycle "Tour du Lac St-Jean", for example, is a way of STRONG I! ' . m II 11 !JIB'N I all II I ([I la==„:== III Il I;: /Ij I ll I K' P m all I' ~spp4 l u InII ! Lte M a 41 I .;II iui~ all@ Relations between the visitors from Alma and the people of Bogandd ~liter have gone far beyond the purely interprofessional. Bx-Mayor of Alina with Bogande Municipal staff visiting a man-made water basin. FEB-t 848 I I P ~I P . Illnh ~ 44 Iaig~.l:ll '! '.lii llII [ ll inn Sl pvaa I 1 ~ 4 i II 44 1 I'i i " III!I lilrmi'! - II 'I l ul ~ I I .! ': ' ' a nl l I I I LR sl IHlw 'I I I I a I ~ 'P ' 44 I 1 l'44 ll i ll '"--ll 'I! '" hall I ~ II '--' I '-; ~ ' aa I i nai lg1 PIJIP ala pa nil !,I,sr ah ah!In-Iiiitll laa4 I'I.1 lialahiaiiillu.....I'~ !i i i l ~ I I '' Inma! ~ ~ ~ 11 I 4444 141 ''nl 4 li I =—. „ !!bi I! 1 n r" III IIIII!/ i I!Q ! 'i I II% = r I I I ~ "-: =.=alai,l!,Ill IIRnalsllhllllnala 5111-. /Ii il 1!II ! 411 ! l 'l1 II II M ilr "aa I I I ! I I ll I,'111 I~Is gl 'ltlll 101! NI" ia PI I I I ll I 11 I I I ll hill L I l I Ill! I itiiIiiilI I I la I Ilail . II I 32 Federrrnon of Canaaiian Municipalities 1 11 jiriIIIia„ i I! I 4444!4 1! iii ililil I , I i ! I I I L j ill Ill I I 44 II I sons b'ec, illa I ape'o'und:le'sr 4'.1'1-4 I II I I e.learn ed,'.::Inn Qui- one ''usledd: 'to::::a I la ~ because City Hall houses people who are committed," underlines Gervais L'Heureux. ",Miinager's'. ~ ~ 'l l 'al orkiiig the:::situation givess one: Is hfe Qne:. good eeiiig 18ogan'de hui~n i'ii ucch the':,Plp relations 6%i@ere'I rehiiri'ed g:.h''u4 h alhl- . — "Managers who have gone to Burkina have found lessons to be learned. In Quebec, one gets used to a standard of life, to good working conditions. Seeing the situation in Bog andd gives one some humility. One also learns much by the way people there have retained the strong human warmth, in their business relations as well as their day-to-day life, something we have lost a little of here," concludes Jean-Claude Lusinchi. I I lnllh ~ I'! ', i, ! i/I! i,i 1! IL I ! l !I I!I ill III Il ',!! l,A',I ! I il 2 as their day-to-.day life, s'omei hing we ,hape lost, a'.httle::.of he re, "concludes Jean-Claude Lusincki. n' '" 'l lit Il I r « I I Ila'll!' I Ja» 11 III I'I I I n II 1 r flil'I I I ' ! ~ 4 I,'lllll ' I I'!I II l 'lla!,i l 14 4 ill« IR I I II II leal 1 li i I :'ii'i " '-''ill $ '/'IIiI =="" ''- 'g ni tgstlls'ieu''" "'- ''--":"'" '" iwu 'H I . !)gI Tll 4 4 ll! I I I' IllI, i lhlll 9a iiiiii ill I I Ii gl I[l'i Together we can change our world 'Ii . - !I II A 33 ¹w Focus From iI! i il fi II @ I I 1llhlt, lur I I Bank I I: i I power in local governments. Municipal politicians are closer to the electorate, so the chances are good that their policies will better reflect community interests and needs. FAlTH IN THE LOCAL POPULATION Such is the case with the MDP - the Municipal Development Program - a World Il ~ II The old days are gone. Northeners in Africa, brimming with good intentions, carrying briefcases bulging with suggestions and strategies and European or North-American solutions. Now, though the intentions are still the best, the partnership is enriched, reborn as the South works with the South. /II. III)I IIIII IhHI'rrived II 4 ! 'IULI I,' Iiii I II I!hnlii IIII I I, % IILi! I:" /I I'l! l ll!'Igll gJ I» 1ll l g il.l Ill ill Il li I Worth to South I '' IIF,. III III .hllI ' i I!I I Ii 'II iili I I I brainchild sponsored in part by the Federation of C a n a d i a n Municipalities. This 1991 conabora«ve effort by various development agencies =..:: ':: ..., The challenge facing the Municipal Development Program is nonetheless huge. In Africa, it is exactly at the community level that the lack of human resources and ., the institutional weaknesses are most "':. apparent. The strength ',Ãoltr, though:.theintentions are of the Program lies, Stiil the. beSt,'he partnerghip iS fact, right there: a mth m the peop e enriched," reborn as the:South direcdy concerned. NOPkS iuith the SOuth. After all, it is they A who are in the best institutions seeks to position to see what increase municipal government efficiency in must be done and to understand how to do Eastern and Western Africa. it. and frican —— ': '' Over the past years, Sub-Saharan governments, confronted with serious economic crises, have come to the realization that all orders of government must be involved in recovery efforts. African urban populations have doubled in size in the past two decades—even more reason to decentralize and invest more ' ',, 'n Joseph Mugore, MDP Director in Harare, Zimbabwe, puts it this way: "We are getting away from the traditional vision whereby southern municipalities need our technology. With the MDP, they find their own methods and use our technology if they need it. Africans direct their projects, analyze their towns, their problems, their FEB 2 tIIhII! I II I! I,I !h I I 'll I! II l I I I IJ I 1'I ill I III I II /lli.as il II I I 4. ~ I III'III II 'il II ii i I ~ Ii I jj jl j I = I '''ss ,=-. -„„;; I ~ I gl I'I I 1'. =5 51 = jlj1heli-::: Ijj jjjj " "~ l'll gII''111155';1 "o: jlijig I gjI - . [/(jill I -, =:,." 15i ii I ~a ~ "" -= '= ='i, IIII s ss mitl 1 /iii IgI'-'-I" e= g[ Issnth II 5',k5llPIlj' '-':" ll = n~ n I 1 1 I III // fife, ar' gettiii g, aIpay',porn 'the:traditioria~l::,pjsioii ivherre-. .. by', sosutherIg-: ytiuriicip"~aaes ousr,.'ech'jjologjy; WWdN ther tueSthodls,: afjd use. ou techiioEogsy 'igJ."6&heSy, It cad it IlINI which demonstrated a willingness to participate in this type of project — countries where the central governments were open to strengthening municipal governments. 15115 51 51 S51 'he'::3~3DP," t~fiey'-JTrid')Pyg. n ji II n l III 1 I I I 5 II ~ ti ...:I I I ~ u~ 5 successes, their finances. For them, it's a new way to learn." 5 I...;,:.'l'I Illa' I II sill ''--'' -'I I ljli 1 1 Ill = 1 5. 1 The MDP role is not one of investment, but rather one of institutional reinforcement, of "capacity building". "They don't receive money with this project," says Joseph Mugore. "They derive instead the valuable conviction that they can organize themselves." The instigator of this multilateral project, the World Bank, has sought and found several sponsors who offer their ftnancial and technical support. In Canada, the partners are FCM, the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA) 5 and the International Development and Research Center gDRC). The Program also relies on the support of two Europj~ partners, Italy and the Netherlands. principal donor is Italy, followedy Netherlands. Canada intends to inetSC IIS contribution in the next few years. THE WILLINGNESS CHARGE TO As for the African partners, the W'orld Bank approached interested nations II I I till ~ I S I 55 I I 11 The Municipal Development Program has developed four principal sectors of activity: Itis : II 51551» Fedesnsion of Canadian Municipalities II I]IIljl I II'll,":"''-'- I f 34 I I 5 'll lm I 1 'ie'edd-: ill I! I II I I', / i,Ii M '.1'I 1 III a '. Strengthening municipal associations: It -'n this sector that FCM financial support 'oncentmted. Since many municipal -miations in Africa are not effective, this native seeks to bolster them. To this end, .ne International Union of Local Authorities gULA)-Africa Section has been mandated to offer support and services. I sl all 5 155 ISI SI 5 15 5 , Ul 51 II Ii ll l I I I ~ 111 I I'l I I 5 5 iil i lnl 5 Municipal su pport: Municipalities showing both motivation and the ability to take responsibility are offered a program to improve their management systems. For example, the town of KweKwe, Zimbabwe, linked with Fort McMurmy, Alberta, through the "Africa 2000" project, is currently eliminating its deficit. With the help of the MDP, KweKwe is now working on a master development plan. I 11% II 1 3. I' IISSS 11 ~ 55 O 1. Policy: The MDP supports policy research on strengthening local government. 2. Trahajng: This aspect collcentrates primarily on strengthening training facilities for municipal administrators. Institutions which have shown some initial success are assisted and encouraged to help other institutions in the region. The approach fosters both networking and the exchange of .'deas. Regional policy seminars are also offered. Sj I 1 II ~ 1 Ijiii I 'I Pl Ia 5 5 I I ~ — « .— «~n 111 «-' ls I I ~ ~ 3 I I s ." = ISI III III III~ I ~ «NI flit I tli alit I '' 'll'I It iijll'e% I IIL Ilt I ,' I'gll ..: jj .''I s«I~...". =" 0 Ili&IINI N lan«I %«M Illa«III '. I „«- I; I tl late! Ia „u 1111 ~ II s I I II«I a«,hl lltls I m - II I' --' I Slslt S n ' 18!Il gal lflll I Ill Ul I, I d,'"' " I Ill gl 'lip!ill! I IS I n.i I II Il 'l '111 a I ,1 Together we cnn change onr world iilliiii!r I ISN I SIN NEW EXPERTISE FOR FCM According to Andrd Guindon, Africa 2000 Manager at FCM: "With participation in the Municipal Development Program, FCM has enlarged its field of activity and developed new expertise. llew( !Rt !1111 I 'l I I 'I I III I "Until now, we concentrated our activities on links between Canadian cities and those in developing countries. i itm'4 Ill 581 Ill Il II 1 Si SI SI IIIII ~ II» I 'I' g ] 35 Iiii, alII "The arrangement reveals the everincreasing confidence placed in us by CIDA, which asked us to support the project for Canada. !! I"! iilRJ 11 'll I Ii "As well, FCM activity in this project increases our visibility on the national scene, giving us another tool better to represent Canadian municipal interests." II 1 I PI 'II i II II'iili ill,l II S all 'Si I Nli I'oj,l "Now, we move on to another level, participation in South-South initiatives. i 11 IIII Ii I '--' !!". Ill I , I 1: E IIIN ) I IISIIMS ~ ) I 1 I 8 I! I IS 'S I 1 I I ' II «I I I I ~I I I 'll II II II I I I, II III 'II%I I !'J Il I Ill Ii I I II SI II ~ j I I ~~ I « ~ ~1 8 I Il » l il I 1 I I I I hl S 'IMS. « I ll FEB-2 1913 ! I I I all, i «vl Iss ~ uls ig lglssl — I ~ 41I "IP .n !I"I u RS 1 g li S I Ii I If I, I «is I II IRfi 'ii il sin II, ~ iii I 1 =-"I'l s IIliiii IIII llila Irm IILs t 'l I 111 1 " -"-I: 'i| i'l I,'ill.ii ', I I I, It I! 'S ll I I S 'I IIII I, I Ill ~ ~ I It I . 1S l we can change our world 37 SSS I ill ie 3l'll Ill, fIII Nl I I Zi I lml!j~,l 1IR I 9 gll' u l I ll I l I 'l SI ~,11 I I 1il I I I! l'I ii ll, 'I! ILP, il I I I I I I III I lit IS 11 What can your municipality do for International Bevelopment Week9 I II ill jI'" 'l 'I IRk i, to international development, activities that can take place year-round. 11 I ',; ':',jIIII'sIj''Ll eu— lt is now or never - take a leadership role in your community and plan activities relating i fu Ital International Development Week (IDW) is an excellent occasion to open our minds to what goes on outside our borders and to sensitize Canadians to the vital issue of international development. I I, I jm ! — SSS Although these nations are geogmphically distant, we cannot simply ignore their plight. We live in an era of economic and environmental interdependence, and what goes on in these far-away municipalities could well have a real impact on Canadian communities. ;l,',;,', I III '1 lt d ll li I II "'"'-- t In these difficult economic times, problems of developing countries seem unrelated to those faced by Canadian municipalities. )I Ii lIII ll S I . = IPg I I S ~ ttl --' International Development WeekP s s r. i i", LIIS ~ IIS /tt Illnll ~ ' "-—— NAY Participate in I(' I Ilt Isa III i ~ l»» --:- ~ - P'ogether s I I 1111/I IL ' I'I II P ~ 'it I I 'IS%I'.'!.'"'"'-t Ilg - ' M Pn «Ii lelilel Sit/ms '"gp I u Iilmmpml'I ~ I sst¹H~ulmgm nut=! ~l', lllll,!!hlI~ L-..-=,-~g+K':=:I .'% „;; 'I Pill 1 =;~ {Iiml,smasi«~.ismml Ilium tII II ~ "'' "lli I —— - — j!J l II ' I IP i I s Proclaim International Development Week ~ {IDW) {see p. 39); iIli Order promotional material from CIDA for International Development Week. Place IDW II posters in your offices, distribute pamphlets and calendars to municipal employees. This material is offered free of charge by CIDA. Call to order: (819) 997-5006 I 'i I s I'I'i s I u s Combine forces to better coordinate IDW activities in I your municipality. liml 1 ~ Get informed about IDW activities in your community, and participate. Use CIDA's electronic noticeboard to learn which other organizations in your area are planning activities for IDW. You'l need your computer and a n:odem. The CIDA message address is 25. Call for information: (819) 994 - 3857 FEB-2 193 SSS I I i I ~ 111 m ~&iIII'== aeries: '! 4 I I 1 airs&S ':=i I I I a g Z's sir ~ &M nu I 'Isi Iona srs e I'rel'I == siij I Ix:„".-''-.' % i Ilii Il I II i,I' a 'I « a~ace& Sl re iran is~a& PL'I Iti III '! = .e~miiiit!1lili@ Ij I I = —Iistii-„',,Ir& pIf inn sl»ere srerma ~ lls'i is jiIs iu I ia'IISII«,~ — il&&s&a mseesersjI@p /IW'. — — 1&a& Q$ ~,, ils s - p' = '":: it'cia Iil II/jgj p/lire 1»e taa lta'l I sigil]I = n! -aeJ ,:: laa Rl»l& I liiglslltllrari:;; =..—.':.,'... —...,, "'=='= I&,'', gill Iir "'iil I'&ll lliil iiggli 'gill - ': — — — — pi ! I ljl I & »&i ~ sr&II& s irlir i as & rr limni " &' is is I —.— — — . & i ii '' " IIj i — —,-„— i a lttul II!I g , IJ& 11 1 1 pgglitigllg eI~/$ Qgima iimmlg II Iiajlt/ige~ sas ! 'ssa I~esaeaiim ill gI] 11't I I!II I!I iiis ii'ii g III llta II /gjlll'I 'I III '. tIii) ..I Sl 'jij,iI If il IIII IB III 'i! '&'lIl i It II 1)I I 'I'-. .-; I I SIIre r&l i r1r II sale sil lite. 38 f Fedetun'en o Canadian Municipalities s Iiu collaboration with the local Chamber of Commerce, sponsor an annual prize for the I 1 il & I I I!I'jlljl Business or municrtoal agency which has accompiishcd most for international development. ~ Invite a member oi'our community who is working (or who has worked) in Canadian or %I I 1 I PIt II overseas deveiopment to give a lecture with slides or video. Organize a deBate on the importance of development aid. Invite experts, CIDA representatives, or non-governmental organizations (NGOs). You may wish to call on the II'Illlll services of CIDA's Speaker's Bureau. I" iI j I'j'i II&II I II li I I'I 1 III" '' srr''ss ll ' s Make your international activities more visible. ~ Isi rase! ail II ~ iihl! lr Iil I II 11 I r I i l g. e i i is! Ilg I Ull I m - Organize a conference or working lunch with project managers. Using slides, present your projects achievements or their most recent developments. show photos, slides, or souvenirs of your international development activities. &e i j r1 r ji i& I I I 'lil I i re r& - Pubhsh an article on your activities in the municipal newsletter, the regional weekly, I ~ &I ii ae isa i ere ~ I ll or the town's daily paper. Ir IIL 'Ill, Il,. - Set up an information display in the lobby of City Hall or the Municipal Library to ~ r r/[] Iiie Iiai ul s Is 'I I~ I " li - Turn International Deveiopment Week into a fundraiser for whatever projects you plan. I sa ~ I r ill ~ [ i I II I I I I I I,.I iilt r /I lt la 1 r's I' \I I ; I gg IIII er I' ~ su~umsss ss~s~aSS dii ~ ~ III ll I ss ~ is " ssmmSIS ..IIISII ml I ll gluR s It vs Iilsjl isi Is 'll .I I tal ! , i I I Ill lst it jI~z u 111 I s su I I K ss s I ,: 'a% ~ sII —.— -1 ilr~! ' " . — - — SIgg Sru=c:r'«@rills---, s s s rmt v II Il I II::=II:I I I lt '===I s'M I sc — — Wll I S=Z'S~ssgimaSSSIt IS Z Isis ~ s ~ s lies sI ii ~ il is/I ~ Isis is@ 5R sts IIIIIl ts nisi~a 'na~gdlh ti Ig ill!II/',:: I " 2:.Illlgig —, I, i ii lsgssl ~ s s«sSMHI i I g gs sassing I lig III I.. Issmr~aatl~sss ': " ,'g 1N ~,s; I" II Ihi I151II ii!,"I'...',Jj/ t! ill Er ~III E....-sgjkllWNRIll I I I I ".-- -IRSII l~l-" . ~ Jgll + l8 RNlil I sj,~IIIII ma ! tli ascii s I Proclamation: International Development Week I ,'I'IIIII'III Ili, According to information received at the Federation of Canadian Municipalities (FCM), 65 municipalities proclaimed International Development Week in 1992. The previous year, 9 municipalities made such s proclamation. FCM wants to do better in 1993. III'III LI$ / «sll IJ ~ . Proclaiming International Development Week is one simple and inexpensive way to sensitize your II j llsd I i g! s aI citizens to the realities of Southern nations. Following are two possible examples of proclamation that your municipality could use as a modeL J s ~ sls s il,";.:~'II!l ti iIII /seal s i ls isis s WHEREAS the town of XYZ shares the world and a common future with the people in the Develzspiug World; aud s WHEREAS the town of XYZ shares the understanding that aH human beings have the right to the basic necessities of life: food, water, shelter, health care and education; and s WHEREAS the town of XYZ believes in helping people help themselves; and s WHEREAS the town of XYZ wants to build a bridge between our community and people of the Developing World by helping them to gain access to the tools and skills they need to improve Ii III il 'll, 'r'I I'il I]f SI II I li ii THEREFORE BE IT KNOWN THAT we do hereby proclaim that the week of February /th 1993 shall be desi gaated as: INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT WEEK in the town of XYK and we commend its thoughtl'ul observance to all citizens of the city. 1st to , I Its i I I II I Ss PROCLAMATION: INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT WEEK 'I I i II I ill'ill ~ WHEREAS International Development Week ,1 I ~ I will ii' i Ils mfi! !'ilH II ~ uI I s I I',rrsr I!I ', ['I; I i; IV 1 I their situation; aad s WHEREAS together, we can make a World of Difference; 4 ' S III s s ts "'' , II II III, will take place from February 1st to 7th, 1993 ~ Aud WHEREAS we live on a shrinking planet aad what happens in far away developing countries before thought of as remote and unimportant to Canada, often bas a direct impact on us; ~ AND WHEREAS global forces are looming larger and municipal councils are asked to participate aud encourage their citizens to think of aH the communities in our Global Village at this time: 'i.li I 'I I II AND WHEREAS the objective of lnteraational Development Week is to assure the public that change is taking place in the Third World, and to build public support for a saonger foreign aid programme, to increase public understanding of the interdependent nature of our world and the global links between people in our communities and conuuunities throughout the developping il si ' 'I I i I I ~ II. It ill II s I world; ~ AND WHEREAS tbe theme of "helping people to help themselves" can make a lasting .difference to Canadians as well as to people in the Third World, I THEREFORE WE: Tbe Council of the Town of XYZ, do hereby proclaim the week of February 1st to 7th, 1993: "INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT WEEK" within the town of XYZ and urge all citizens to lend their support. DATED at the Town of XYZ, 31st day of January, 1993. 1111 sir I FEB ' I I ~ NOW -2 igll3 I si misaIIIÃnniinnssina arirstwt In% a Ill w/ I j '"" 'g ==mi~illii l=;=:ss imI II: I Iu'".:'-:-, ... Iilme,=,;s,i '~ sl n: ~ l~ I1lg~"'mmlnm «et igggl = 'Hiiil ll |I sas 'Ill gllll."".; IIIlilg egg&I w'„(IIII/'L IIII" "~ ~u Q j ''- O'., ~l m~'=', ~'n"= — : IIII+I'II'~ IaI~ — illus ; .=- ~ X=' wwelillI philln P I I I 1 ~" "w/ MILII'Ihk@51N '=:::'nil ='ill II sg sl all I joe !.III gl lg . I im I IISIIIii igiiil FCAf Internationa/ Program '- -w SNL I Ill Ii I I In 'ru ls/l/ir Il nri — Jl I I i i II I I ~ II i'irilail i mr l I'I II IN I ill Il la 1/iliiu i:= lll ln s i l III I g 'I liii Ii» I o a i I I lrll l,l ~ II r S)/ I u / ~/ Ill, lsni/ /w ~,' 1 I,lsiu,i'ls 'll iiii i')' 'II, I I I I 'l II I I I Ilgg. I II [ s lln i II I l ill I I In li I il' I i /~ For municipalities who are not already registered with FCM's International Offic, International Development Week could be the ideal time to become better informed or to get involved. l Municipal Professional Exchange Program (MPEP) II This program establishes links and promotes technical and professional exchanges on municipal problem-solving. Apart from allowing participating municipalities to share their experiences, MPEP opens doors to trade and investment. The program covers the direct costs of travel and accommodation as well as meals aud incidentals for the participants. China open Cities Project Under this program, local government officials in China's Open Cities and Special Economic Zones benefit fmm trainhg in urban planning, administration, environmental management, and economic development. The project includes technical missions to Canada by mayors and staff of the Chinese cities. These missions consist of intensive theoretical and practical courses. In China, the project offers seminars on Western-style professional development to mayors and vice-mayors and to their staffs. The project also aids Canadian municipalities wishing m establish links with Chinese counterparts. l If Ilmlll 'ijIIi JIlgl lit I 'I ll 1 allis I I 11 II I II ',I! IlrlII llIII 'illl'iI I PII J I ll I liii Iw~' wvr ll I I if I i~i/a/ / / I 'I"ii ~: &id al 1 I \M i Ig 'i ii'in ~/~ll~+x xvrx "i 7l n I i ill / Africa 2000: The Municipal Response i.' 'll '' W LI'll 1 I, Specifically targming Sub-Saharan African nations, the goal of this program is the improvement of municipal management techniques and neighbourhood quality of life. Canadian municipalities can organize links with African municipalities, and can effect exchanges between elected officials, administrators, professionals, and technicians, Funding is provided for such technical exchanges. Openings for private enterprise initiatives are also encouraged. To date, some thirty Canadian and African municipalities are participating in the program, managing together their own cooperative programs. 1 I II I I Ij FEB-2 1S93 l(i 9 I& I ~ e&l& I II I. I I ~ ~ ~ I